Before LUCY LOVES DESI: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Sitcom ever graced The Keeton stage for its Tennessee Premiere (onstage now thru October 26), it had already began its own fascinating chapter in the story of I Love Lucy. Based largely on Laughs, Luck… and Lucy: How I Came to Create the Most Popular Sitcom of All Time—a memoir by I Love Lucy creator Jess Oppenheimer, completed by his son Gregg Oppenheimer in 1996—the play traces the real-life creation of television’s most enduring comedy.
Originally premiering at UCLA’s James Bridges Theatre in 2018 as I Love Lucy: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Sitcom in an L.A. Theatre Works production, the World Premiere featured Sarah Drew (Grey’s Anatomy) as Lucille Ball and Oscar Nuñez (The Office) as Desi Arnaz, and was recorded live for public radio. The piece was later reborn under its current title, LUCY LOVES DESI, for a 2020 BBC Radio 4 broadcast starring Anne Heche and Wilmer Valderrama. Most recently, the play completed a successful 21-city national tour with L.A. Theatre Works in 2023, bringing audiences across the U.S. an intimate, funny, and touching tribute to the groundbreaking sitcom.
Now, it’s Nashville’s turn as The Keeton’s audiences have the chance to experience this love letter to television history, thanks to The Keeton’s delightful and impeccably cast production. Directed by Donna Driver, the show invites audiences behind the curtain (or, more accurately, behind the microphone) to witness how Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz fought to bring their vision to life in a skeptical, male-dominated industry—and how their persistence changed entertainment forever.
During Driver’s welcome remarks on Opening Night, she very kindly made mention that it was yours truly who had suggested the play be part of their current season, so you know I loved that. She also informed the audience that the playwright had been very accessible via numerous phone calls and emails during preparation and rehearsal for The Keeton’s production, even writing new scenes and adding in vignettes featuring classic musical moments from I Love Lucy to allow The Keeton’s production of the show to expand from its original one-act length to a full two-act show. In doing so, The Keeton’s production captures both the warmth and wit that defined I Love Lucy while reminding us that innovation often begins with risk.
The Keeton’s scenic designer, Kevin Driver’s clever set—the backdrop transformed into a vintage 21” wooden cabinet tv, upscaled to about 10’x10’, complete with old-school antenna—allowed the audience visuals for scene changes by way of stills projected onto the large tv screen of locations like CBS & Desilu Studios and The Arnaz’s Palm Springs home. Completing the set, simple chairs for the actors to sit while not featured, and the side stage riser all come together to evoke the golden age of live radio, complete with period microphones, a glowing “On Air” sign, and a prominently featured Foley table manned with precision and playfulness by Beverly Grant, whose sound effects artistry earns laughs all its own. You’ll likely find ourself looking up at the Foley table more to catch Grant’s antics from time to time.
I always correct folks when they introduce me as a theatre critic, preferring the term reviewer, but I have to be truthful, being a huge Lucille Ball fan and longtime memorabilia collector of both her I Love Lucy years and her film career before (and yes, even her years after), I came into the evening with reservations, with my critic hat fully in place. I also have to admit that I was, overall, pleasantly and thankfully surprised at just how sweetly, lovingly and honorably the cast of The Keeton presented the backstory of how my favorite comedy actress and her Cuban bandleader husband made television history.
The way this performance is structured, Jason Rainwater’s Desi Arnaz steps in and out of the action of the play to talk directly to the audience. As Desi Arnaz, Rainwater delivers a winning performance full of charisma and authenticity. As he mentioned during our recent Rapid Fire 20Q when I questioned him on the authenticity of his Desi voice, his vocal work is uncanny—so richly textured and musically accurate that it often truly sounds like Arnaz himself. The chemistry between Rainwater and Grace Gaddy as Lucy is the stuff of which stage pairings are made; together they bring the Ball–Arnaz partnership to life with warmth, wit, and a rhythm that feels instinctual. Just as one would imagine him, Rainwater’s Desi is a charmer, a showman, a proud immigrant and a great example of a mid-century business man and entertainer who redefined what it is to live the American dream.
While none of the cast truly look like their real-life counterparts, it’s not an impersonator show in Las Vegas, after all, Grace Gaddy’s Lucille Ball is, when all is said and done, a loving tribute to the iconic comedian. From her expressive eyes and impeccable comic timing to the way she embodies Lucy’s signature blend of glamour and goofiness, Gaddy gives a performance that’s joyously alive. Her physicality and facial expressions elicit hearty laughter while paying true homage to one of television’s greatest icons. My only hesitation in a giving Gaddy’s Lucilly Ball a full five star review rests on the fact that Gaddy’s choice of voice isn’t quite there. Yes, Lucille Ball’s real-life voice was quite different from her quicker, higher-pitched Lucy Ricardo voice, but Gaddy, try as she may, never quite hits the mark vocally. Of course the average Keeton audience member will easily overlook this because of Gaddy’s otherwise full-force embodiment of the iconic comedic actress. It should be noted that Gaddy’s Lucy is at her best not only when recreating a few classic I Love Lucy moments–her lip-smacking, face-pulling expressions during a quick look at Vitameatavegamin is indeed near-perfection–but also during scenes that show the rarer more vulnerable moment of the woman behind the legendary laughs.
Even though he plays the man upon whose book this play is based, Michael Welch has the benefit of playing someone most people have never seen and whose physical appearance isn’t as easily recognized as the four stars of the groundbreaking sitcom. That anonymity works to Welch’s advantage as he simply shines as Jess Oppenheimer, serving as the grounding force amid the behind-the-scenes chaos. His balance of humor and sincerity keeps the story engaging and human. His scenes between Gaddy’s Lucy and Rainwater’s Desi truly exemplify Oppenheimer’s role as both close friend and trusted collaborator in the creating of one of the world’s most beloved sitcoms.
Cassidy Davis is delightful as Betty Garrett, a close pal of Lucille Ball’s who happens by the radio studio in a brief scene early on. Again, pop culture nerd that I am, I feel compelled to remind you that Garrett, a radio and film star like Ball in their early days, also gained fame on television—for roles on All in the Family and Laverne & Shirley (Garret played the girls’ landlord and Laverne’s eventual step-mom). I do wish there’d been time for a wig change as Garrett was more often a brunette. But yes, I’m just being picky. However, it’s Davis’ Vivian Vance that’s key to the story. Davis plays Vance a little sweeter, a little lighter than the real actress and again, there seems to be no concern for sounding like the original. Nonetheless, Davis nails each of her many roles—from Betty Garrett and various secretaries throughout to Vivian Vance and even a male executive at one point—with comedic grace and sharp timing. Again, does she really look or even sound like Vance? No, but does she deliver the goods? Yes.
Living up to his last name, Brian Best as William Frawley, is indeed, the best at fully embodying the role. Best turns in a masterclass of voice acting. His portrayal of William Frawley is eerily accurate, perfectly capturing Frawley’s gravelly timbre and gruff charm, while also handling multiple other characters—including network head William Paley—and with more than a bit of a smokers cough, Best’s Parker McComas, President of I Love Lucy sponsor Philip Morris, is a scene stealer. Rounding out the ensemble, Eric Crawford, Chris Hill, and Tony Bernui each contribute energetic and distinctive performances that heighten the show’s humor. Crawford’s facial reactions, Hill’s authoritarian vibe and Bernaui’s ability to switch from portraying Lucille’s early radio husband, the dashing Richard Denning, to I Love Lucy season one director and friend of Vivian Vance, the theatrically flamboyant Marc Daniels, all add to the fun of the piece.
Musically, this expanded version of the show delights with nostalgic selections that evoke memories of classic I Love Lucy episodes, including I’ll See You in C-U-B-A, Friendship, California Here I Come, and the beloved I Love Lucy theme song, complete with a bit of a did you know who wrote it spoiler and Rainwater and Gaddy singing the rarely heard lyrics. Enhancing the musical score throughout, frequent Keeton musical director Roger Hutson’s piano recordings add a lighthearted, era-appropriate touch, while Steve Love’s sound design, Brooke Sanders’ lighting, wig design by Alison Gaddy (loosen up those wigs so they look more natural and like the real-life ladies they’re styled after) and Denese René Evans’ costumes work in harmony to transport the audience straight to midcentury Hollywood. Evans’ costumes throughout are quite fun and seemingly period authentic, I do wish that Lucille’s Emmy dress was accurate, through…again, I’m just being an overzealous Lucy fan.
In spite of my above-reference initial hesitations and a strangely tepid Opening Night audience (Note: it’s ok to laugh out loud and to applaud after a particularly entertaining scene) and what could probably be chalked up to first night jitters from the cast resulting in the majority of Act 1’s delivery being a tad flat with several lines coming across as monotone with not real inflection and somewhat memorized, rather than convincingly felt and delivered with punch, those initial hesitations faded once the cast found their groove.
Bottom line, The Keeton’s LUCY LOVES DESI is a sentimental, heartfelt tribute to two of television’s most influential pioneers and the creative force behind them that believed America just might take to heart the story of a zany redhead and her latin love. Equal parts history lesson, love story, and nostalgic romp, it captures the magic that made I Love Lucy timeless—and proves that behind every great laugh is a story worth telling.
LUCY LOVES DESI: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Sitcom runs through October 26 at The Keeton Dinner Theatre, oh and speaking of dinner, just like Lucy enjoyed at The Brown Derby, in the February 7, 1955 Season 4 episode of I Love Lucy titled L.A. at Last, The Keeton is serving up Spaghetti and Meatballs with a side salad and croissant and dessert for the pre-show dinner. CLICK HERE for tickets and showtimes.
If you happened to miss my recent Rapid Fire 20Q with the cast, CLICK HERE to check it out.
Following LUCY LOVES DESI: A FUNNY THING HAPPENED ON THE WAY TO THE SITCOM, The Keeton’s current season continues with SHE LOVES ME, onstage December 4-21, BIG FISH, running February 6-22, THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG April 10-26, with STATE FAIR closing the season June 13-29! CLICK HERE for tickets and more details.
So you don’t miss out on upcoming shows at The Keeton Dinner Theatre, follow them on Facebook, X and Instagram.
Interested in coverage for your latest entertaining endeavor? Click the contact page and drop me a note. You can also follow JHP Entertainment on Instagram and Facebook. In the meantime, #GoSeeTheShow!