Tamiko Robinson Steele

Theatre Review: Nashville Rep’s It’s A Wonderful Life’ Delivers A Heartfelt triumph for the Holiday Season

December 10, 2025 by Jonathan

Nashville Repertory Theatre rings in the season with a warmly nostalgic, creatively staged production of It’s A Wonderful Life, directed by Alicia Lark Fuss and running now through December 22 at TPAC’s Polk Theater. With a stellar cast led by Brian Charles Rooney as George Bailey, Tamiko Robinson Steele as Mary Hatch Bailey, Jennifer Whitcomb-Oliva as Clarence and Matthew Carlton doing double duty as both Joseph, the supervising angel and as Potter, the beloved Frank Capra holiday classic, adapted for the stage by playwright Catherine Bush, is reimagined with theatrical magic.

This production leans into nostalgia while embracing a distinctly theatrical vocabulary with inventive movement, actors portraying multiple roles throughout and a visually stunning pop-up vintage Christmas card aesthetic —resulting in a version of Bedford Falls that feels both timeless and newly alive, all adding fresh dimension to a story generations know by heart.

Before a single line is spoken, the audience is transported by Gary C. Hoff’s breathtaking set design: a larger-than-life, die-cut, layered pop-up tableau rendered like a mid-century Christmas card cut from heavy white cardstock. It’s whimsical without being precious—an intricate snowy sculpture of Bedford Falls, with tiny cut-out doorways and windows glowing from within. Peer closely and you’ll catch vintage cyanotype portrait photos, representing the “everyday people” of the town, those whose quiet lives shape George Bailey’s world in ways he often forgets to see. It’s the perfect conceptual anchor for a story about taking note of what truly matters.

Playwright Bush seems to have taken inspiration from such classic theatre pieces as Our Town, in employing the above-mentioned practice of having actors portray multiple roles. Another of this production’s most enchanting elements is its use of movement. Thanks to movement coordinator Megan Castleberry, the ensemble shifts with a near-balletic grace—actors gracefully glide set pieces to and fro, and when called for, they physically personify snow gusts, swirling wind and fateful cracks across an icy pond. They mime-like movements echo emotional beats, and embody natural forces, adding a magical, abstract layer to the storytelling. It’s a bold directorial choice that works beautifully, enhancing the narrative without ever distracting from it. Especially effective in the more dramatic scenes, offering them up in an almost dreamlike vision.

At the center is Brian Charles Rooney, who’s made quite a name for himself, not only on the local level, but for his work in New York on Broadway, is well-known for his vocal prowess as a musical theatre powerhouse. Rooney captures the full breadth of George’s life journey—from mischievous boy to wide-eyed dreamer to the exhausted, cornered adult wondering where everything went wrong. Remarkably, he accomplishes this not through drastic physical transformation but through subtle, sharply observed choices: a shift in vocal pitch, a slight change in posture, the weight of responsibility settling into the shoulders. These gradations make his downward spiral heartbreaking and his redemption cathartic. As George Bailey, it’s his sincere believability as the multi-faceted depth he brings to the stage that holds the audience’s attention from that first appearance of a man defeated to the much-loved ringing of that angelic bell signifying all is well with the world. His performance as George Bailey is nothing short of revelatory. And YES…though this production is not a musical, the audiences is indeed treated to just a bit of Rooney’s pitch-perfect multi-octave voice for a quick little verse of Buffalo Gals, the beloved tune featured in the 1946 film classic.

As Mary Hatch Bailey, Tamiko Robinson Steele radiates warmth, quiet confidence, and fierce devotion. Her Mary is not simply the supportive spouse—she’s the emotional compass of the story, grounding George even when he’s flailing hardest. Steele’s effortless sincerity elevates every scene she touches. From their scenes depicting George and Mary’s childhood friendship to their teenage flirtation, Steele’s sweet embodiment of Mary is palpable. The scene at the drugstore soda fountain when Mary leans over to George and whispers in his bad ear her devotion, I couldn’t help but have a little eye sweat. With Steele in the role, it’s no wonder George offers Mary the moon.

A standout among the ensemble, Matthew Carlton impressively toggles between two primary characters, the compassionate, celestial Joseph and the acerbic, conniving Mr. Potter. The contrasts are stark yet fully realized. Particularly striking is a small but brilliant acting detail: Carlton’s decision to have the wheelchair-bound Potter occasionally rub his leg, as if easing a persistent ache. As someone with mobility and neuromuscular pain myself, that gesture resonated deeply—an understated physical cue that hints at the discomfort and bitterness fueling Potter’s worldview. Carlton’s scenes with apprentice angel, Clarence are equally as lovely.

To that end, Jennifer Whitcomb-Oliva, who I readily admit is one of my longtime theatre crushes, shines brilliantly as the eager-to-earn-his-wings Clarence. Ever-hopeful and constantly assuming its his time to get to work helping George as Carlton’s Joseph guides him through George’s journey thus far, Witcomb-Oliva is simply joyous to behold. Also tasked with also presenting the bumbling but big-hearted Uncle Billy, Witcomb-Oliva os equally at ease. Where physical choices and minute nuances in characterization are concerned, Witcomb-Oliva is astutely adept. From Clarence’s nervous excitement to not only help George, but to also earn is wings–to Uncle Billy’s blissful befuddlement, Witcomb-Oliva delivers performances indeed worthy the presentation of angel wings.

Among the remaining company members, Matthew Benenson Cruz offers charm and humor as Harry Bailey, Burt the Cop, and more. Garris Wimmer deftly give the ole “Hee-haw!” to his Sam Wainwright, offers a bit kindness with his Mr. Gower and is the perfect companion to Cruz’s Burt as Ernie the cabbie. (Side Note: As I do every time I have the chance to review It’s A Wonderful Life, YES, I will point out the fact that Jim Henson and Company got the names for two of Sesame Street’s best pals from the characters of Bert and Ernie in the Capra classic), but I digress. Back to the ensemble, as expected, Eve Petty gives a spirited turn as Violet Bick, injecting just the right note of vulnerability beneath the flirtation. She’s also ridiculously fun in her role as one of the Bailey children.

Among the remaining ensemble are Eric D. Pasto Crosby, who is first seen in a brief appearance as Mr. Bailey and a little more stage time as Nick the barkeep (question…did they really have Sports Bars called as such in the 1940s? It’s rhetorical. Sports Bars weren’t a thing until the 1960s, thus my only complaint about the set, for when Clarences shows George what life would have been like had he not been born, they visit the bar formerly owned by Martini, now emblazoned with a mirror-etched sign reading Nick’s Sports Bar). Aleia Eagleton and Darci Nalepa Elam appear throughout portraying various townspeople. Among their standout turns, Elam’s Ma Bailey is motherly perfection while her Tilley is flirty and fun. Then there’s the small in stature, but big in energetic presence of Eagleton as she is fabulously convincing and utterly enjoyable in the tiny, but pivotal role of Zuzu.

Each member of the company, whether featured on ensemble beautifully adding texture, warmth, and an essential presence throughout, rounding out the world of Bedford Falls with the perfect blend of authenticity, heart and the occasional wink to cleverness of the minimal approach to the piece.

Behind the scenes, the talent runs as deep. Melisa K. Durmon’s costumes, hair, and makeup perfectly capture the era while allowing each actor to glide seamlessly between roles and meet those quick change cues in time for their next character’s appearance. Dalton Hamilton’s lighting design bathes the stage in comforting holiday hues one moment and stark emotional shadows the next, guiding the audience through George’s shifting state of mind, but never over-dramatizing it. Kevin O’Donnell’s sound design subtly enhances the production’s magical realism—gentle chimes, rustling winds, and atmospheric underscoring that support without overwhelming.

Nashville Rep’s It’s A Wonderful Life is more than a nostalgic retelling; it’s a reminder—tender, inventive, and beautifully crafted—of the impact one life can have on an entire community. With its inventive staging, standout performances, and thoughtful direction, this production radiates the very heart of the holidays. Whether you’re revisiting Bedford Falls or discovering it for the first time, this beautifully crafted production is a heartfelt story of community, compassion, gratitude, connection, and the timeless belief that no one is a failure who has friends and the reminder of the difference one life can make.

The Rep‘s It’s A Wonderful Life continues its run through December 21, with performances at 7:30pm Thursday, December 18 and Fridays and Saturdays, and 2pm matinees Saturdays and Sundays. Truly a heartfelt, artfully realized gift to Nashville theatergoers, so grab your tickets, your Bevin Silver Bell, and maybe a tissue or two and get ready to head to TPAC‘s Polk Theatre to celebrate this Wonderful piece of American holiday history. CLICK HERE to purchase tickets.

Before you go, in case you missed it, CLICK HERE to check out my recent Rapid Fire 20Q with the director and cast members of the show.

Following It’s A Wonderful Life, Nashville Rep’s season continues in the new year with FAT HAM, James Ijames‘ Pulitzer Prize-winning reinvention of Hamlet, a co-production alongside Nashville Shakespeare Festival, onstage February 13-22, followed by the audience favorite SISTER ACT April 10-19. Closing out the season will be Amy Tofte‘s BLOOD SUCKING LEECH, as part of Nashville Rep‘s New Works: Next Stage, after having presented a staged reading of Tofte’s work just last season. CLICK HERE to purchase Season Tickets.

As always, check out Nashville Rep online and follow them on Facebook, X, YouTube and Instagram.

If you wanna follow JHPEntertainment to find out who I’m chatting with for my next Rapid Fire Q&A, or for my take on the latest local and national theatre, music and movie offerings, find us at JHPEntertainment on Facebook JHPEntertainment on Instagram and JHPEntertainment on Twitter. Got an event or show we should know about, drop us a line at the Contact tab. Till then, #GoSeeTheShow!

Rapid Fire Q&A with Director and Cast of Reimagining of Martin Luther King Jr.’s last night, ‘The Mountaintop’; at Nashville Rep through February 23

February 21, 2025 by Jonathan

Nashville Repertory Theatre‘s current offering, The Mountaintop, written by Katori Hall presents a fictional, yet thought-provoking representation of what Dr. Martin Luther King‘s last night of earth might have been like. Directed for Nashville Rep by Alicia Haymer, the two-person play (now onstage at TPAC‘s Johnson Theatre through Sunday, February 23), stars Rashad Rayford as Dr. King and Tamiko Robinson Steele as Camae, a motel maid, who thanks to Hall’s clever script, gets a suprisingly personal one-on-one chance meeting with the history-making Civil Rights leader. The entirety of the action of The Mountaintop takes place in room 306 of Memphis’ now-infamous Lorraine Motel on the evening of April 3, 1968, the night before Dr. King’s assassination. Last week, as cast and crew prepared to open the show, I had the honor of chatting with director and both stars for my latest Rapid Fire Q&A. What follow are those conversations.

RAPID FIRE Q&A WITH DIRECTOR AND CAST OF NASHVILLE REP’s THE MOUNTAINTOP

RAPID FIRE Q&A WITH THE MOUNTAINTOP DIRECTOR, ALICIA HAYMER

JHPENTERTAINMENT: As The Mountaintop director, what do audiences need to know going in?

ALICIA HAYMER: Whatever you’re expecting, this isn’t it. We often see the larger than life Dr King persona, but this is a reimagining of the man.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: In preparation of chatting with you and your cast, I read the script since I’ve never seen a production of The Mountaintop. I was immediately stuck by how playwright Katori Hall’s fictionalize account of Dr. King’s last night humanizes him. Is that humanization of the icon part of what drew you to this particular project?

ALICIA HAYMER: Absolutely. Katori Hall approached this idea in such a unique way. I couldn’t pass up the opportunity to tell this story, and work with my dear friends Rashad and Tamiko.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: Speaking of the script, early on when Dr. King and Camae comment on the rain, Camae simply remarks, “God ain’t gonna stop crying no time soon”. That line really hit me. Do you have a favorite line in the show?

ALICIA HAYMER: Yes! “Take the baton and pass, pass, pass it along!” We must all continue to do the work necessary to move our society forward.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: When directing a two-person play as opposed to a larger cast, how important is blocking/staging, and how have you addressed it with The Mountaintop?

ALICIA HAYMER: It’s much easier with two actors. The important thing about blocking is that it feels organic and authentic. I don’t want two robots on stage, but two people living and moving truthfully in the moment.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: I’m about to chat with your two actors, so I’d like to ask you…what is is about Rashad Rayford’s performances as Dr. King and Tamiko Robinson Steele’s turn as Camae that you hope audiences take note of most?

ALICIA HAYMER: Rashad has done extensive research to bring Dr. King to life in this unique way. I hope audiences resonate with the spirit of Dr. King that he invokes in his own authentic way. As for Tamiko, she is so brilliant, and brings such light and earnestness to Camae. I hope audiences see that any person, no matter how insignificant they believe themselves to be, can do extraordinary things.

RAPID FIRE Q&A WITH RASHAD RAYFORD, DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. IN NASHVILLE REP’s THE MOUNTAINTOP

JHPENTERTAINMENT: Alright, I need a little clarity to start…Your show bio indicates that The Mountaintop marks your Rep debut, but didn’t you appear in a 2012 staged reading of A Behanding in Spokane with The Rep?

RASHAD RAYFORD: I did the staged reading for A Behanding in Spokane. You are correct. This will be my mainstage debut.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: It’s not your first time playing the role of Dr. King in The Mountaintop, having appeared as the legendary Civil Rights leader in the regional premiere back in 2012. In the years since you first stepped into the role, have you discovered nuances in the role that you’re bringing to this performance?

RASHAD RAYFORD: Definitely, I’ve grown as a person, I was newly married, with no children back then. My wife and I now have four children, and 13 years of marriage and life experiences under my belt. There are so many differences between now and then. It’s been great to discover new things along the way this time.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: This show also serves as a bit of an on-stage reunion with your costar, Tamiko Robinson Steele, having shared the stage with her in The Piano Lesson, Never Been Home and 70% More (and a few film projects if my research serves me well). I have been enthralled by Tamiko from the first time I saw her on stage. She is truly a gift to Nashville’s theatre community. What is is about Tamiko’s talent that makes her the ideal scene partner?

RASHAD RAYFORD: I’ve known Tamiko for almost twenty years now and she is truly family. She is the consummate professional, and her work ethic and dedication are inspiring. We have this great ability to play off of each other and energize each other onstage. I always enjoy sharing the stage with actors who “get it”. The depths of her character development and understanding nuance. It’s a pleasure to watch her work.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: You’ve also shared the stage with your director, Alicia Haymer. As a director, how has she helped bring out your best performances in this show?

RASHAD RAYFORD: This is the first time Alicia has directed me, and I’ve appreciated her approach. She allows us to make decisions, but she also has enhanced what we’re doing, and pushed us to go further and get uncomfortable so that we could find comfort. She is a great director. It’s been an awesome experience.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: What do you hope audiences take with them after having seen The Mountaintop?

RASHAD RAYFORD: I hope audiences walk away knowing that they are enough. Wherever they are in their journey, they can get to The Mountaintop and they can also help others get there too.

RAPID FIRE Q&A WITH TAMIKO ROBINSON STEELE, CAMAE IN NASHVILLE REP’s THE MOUNTAINTOP

JHPENTERTAINMENT: Alright, just to begin…When I saw that you were playing Camae in The Rep’s The Mountaintop, I was so excited. I mean…you gotta know you’re among what I’ve always referred to as my ‘theatre crushes’. Who is Camae to you?

TAMIKO ROBINSON STEELE: First of all, I love that I’m on your ‘theatre crush’ list…I’ll take that honor! Camae, to me, is lightning in a bottle. She’s quick-witted, sharp as a blade, and carries a presence that is impossible to ignore. But beyond the humor and fire, she’s a mirror and a reckoning. She forces Dr. King, and the audience, to see him as more than just an icon, but a man with fears, flaws, and a fate he can’t outrun. Playing her is like stepping into a storm and a sermon at the same time, she is divine mischief, raw truth, and boundless energy wrapped in one unforgettable woman.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: As I mentioned to Alicia, prior to chatting with you all, I read the script as I was only vaguely familiar with the work. I love Camae’s spiritedness. Is that part of what drew you to this role?

TAMIKO ROBINSON STEELE: Absolutely! Camae is spirit and spark. She’s unpredictable, she flips the energy in the room on its head, and she refuses to be boxed in by expectation. But what truly drew me to her is what’s underneath all that fire, her purpose. She is sent for a reason, and watching her navigate that tension between her humor and her mission, between being in awe of Dr. King and challenging him, makes her one of the most deliciously layered roles I’ve ever stepped into. It’s exhilarating to play someone who gets to challenge history itself while still keeping you laughing, questioning, and on the edge of your seat.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: Before opening weekend, The Rep shared a sneak peek at the set designed by Gary C. Hoff. Is there an aspect of the set or a piece that the audience might miss that you find particularly interesting?

TAMIKO ROBINSON STEELE: Oh, that Gary C. Hoff! His sets always transport you somewhere. One thing I love is how the small details ground you in the time period—from the textures to how they may shift when the light hits it, it’s like stepping into 1968 itself. But there’s also a subtle unease in the space, a feeling that something bigger is at play. I won’t spoil too much, but let’s just say this set has a way of shifting right when you least expect it, much like the story itself.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: When I spoke with Rashad Rayford, I noted that you two have shared the stage a handful of times in the past. This show also reunites you with director Alicia Haymer, who directed you in Nashville Rep’s School Girls; or The African Mean Girls Play. Is there a bit of advice or direction that Alicia has offered that opened up a new perspective of Camae to you?

TAMIKO ROBINSON STEELE: Rashad and Alicia are family to me. I can’t express how much knowing that the three of us would build this world together excited me! Alicia has this incredible way of finding the heart inside every scene. One thing she pushed me to do was to honor the stillness in moments because Camae is such an electric presence, it’s easy to play into the fast-talking, sharp-witted firecracker side of her. But Alicia reminded me that Camae doesn’t just disrupt, she listens, she absorbs, she knows exactly when to hold back and when to strike. That balance is what makes her so powerful. Working with Alicia again has been a gift, because she trusts her actors while also making sure every choice we make serves the story in a real and honest way.

JHPENTERTAINMENT: Why should audiences see The Mountaintop?

TAMIKO ROBINSON STEELE: Because it’s not just a play, it’s an experience. It takes one of the most monumental figures in history and lets you see him as a man, tired, flawed, afraid, funny, hopeful, real. It makes you laugh, think, and wrestle with what it means to carry the weight of change. And then, just when you think you know where it’s going, it flips everything on its head.

This play is urgent, intimate, and unforgettable. It reminds us that history isn’t just something we look back on, it’s something we’re still shaping, right now. So if you come to see The Mountaintop, be prepared. You’ll leave differently than when you walked in.

———-

Nashville Repertory Theatre‘s The Mountaintop continues through February 23 with performances Friday, February 21 at 7:30pm, Saturday, February 22 matinee at 2pm and Saturday evening at 7:30pm and a final performance Sunday, February 23 at 2pm. CLICK HERE for tickets.

Next up at Nashville Rep, it’s Sondheim‘s Sunday in the Park with George, with performances April 4-13. Sunday will be directed by Jason Spelbring, with musical direction by Steve Kummer. In the roles of Georges Seraut and George it’s London West End favorite, Irish actor, David Shannon (Les Miserables, The Phantom of the Opera, Sweeney Todd). Just announced, the cast will also feature Christine Dwyer (Broadway‘s Wicked, National Tours of Waitress, Finding Neverland, RENT). Dwyer will take on the roles of Dot and Marie. The cast also includes Nancy Allen as Old Lady, Sejal Mehta as Nurse, James Crawford as Jules, Carrie Brewer as Yvonne, James Rudolph as Boatman, Ian Frazier as Franz, Maria Logan as Frieda, Richard Harrison Jr. as Soldier, Scott Rice as Mr., Christine Toole as Celeste #1, Mariah Parris as Celeste #2, and Brynn Pray as Louise. CLICK HERE for tickets.

As always, check out Nashville Rep online and follow them on Facebook, X, YouTube and Instagram.