During the time Neil Simon’s BAREFOOT IN THE PARK played Broadway, the prolific playwright was enjoying major success, at one point having a total of four plays running simultaneously on the Great White Way. For its initial effort, the play received four Tony nods, taking home Best Director for Mike Nichols. Opening in 1963 and closing in 1967, BAREFOOT IN THE PARK become Simon’s longest-running Broadway show, and Broadway’s tenth longest-running non-musical ever. The year the play closed on Broadway, a film adaptation premiered in theaters, transferring the success of the show to the big screen and widening the audience to movie-goers world-wide.
With such rich history, it’s no wonder The Keeton Dinner Theater has chosen BAREFOOT IN THE PARK as their latest endeavor. Directed by Lenny West and starring Regan Aycock, Evan Fenne, Aleah Christian, Steve Mook and Chad Stem, The Keeton’s BAREFOOT IN THE PARK opens Friday, April 11 and continues through Sunday, April 27. Earlier this week, literally days before the show’s opening, I had a chance to chat with the director and three of the show’s stars for my latest Rapid Fire 20Q. What follows are those conversations.
—————
Rapid Fire 20 Q with director and cast of The Keeton’s BAREFOOT IN THE PARK
Rapid Fire with BAREFOOT IN THE PARK’s Corie, Regan Aycock
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What can you tell me about Corie Bratter, the character you play in The Keeton’s BAREFOOT IN THE PARK?
REGAN AYCOCK: She’s so lovely, she loves life, she loves love, she’s quick to emotion, but quite literally always just wants to have a good time. I think Corie is the little voice in the back of all of our heads that tells us to get mad or get excited, or cry tears of joy. She’s truly all of us, especially those of us who are in love. On the surface though, she’s a 21-year-old new wife that’s trying to start her life with her new husband. Just a girl.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: In preparing to chat with you and the other company members of BAREFOOT IN THE PARK, I discovered the 1981 HBO presentation starring Richard Thomas, Bess Armstrong and Barbara Barrie is available on YouTube. Pretty sure I saw it back then, but It’s been years since I’ve seen this Neil Simon classic live on stage. How excited are you to be part of this particular production?
REGAN AYCOCK: Funny you mention it! That production is actually how I memorized Cories lines, I listened to it day in and day out for weeks in order to get lines down! As for excitement—you have no idea. I wept like a baby when Lenny offered me Corie. I’ve been off the stage for quite some time now, and Barefoot auditions were simply just to get my feet wet again in terms of acting. I had no inclination that I would get Corie. Now I get to spend a little time with her every day. When I told Lenny I was going to take good care of her, I meant it. This is also such a lifelong goal of mine. I’ve been doing theatre for over a decade, and I can’t say I’ve ever been THE girl. Every actor has that dream of getting to lead a show, and Lenny gave me the opportunity to cross that off my list–It just so happens that Corie is also genuinely lovely. I’ll thank him every day for the experience.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: BAREFOOT IN THE PARK takes place in a small New York apartment of newlyweds Corie and Paul Bratter. In fact, the first half-hour of the play centers around the young marrieds settling in, so I gotta ask…What do you remember most about your first apartment after moving out from your parent’s home?
REGAN AYCOCK: I still live in it! I was very fortunate to have some help moving from St. Louis to Nashville, so my apartment wasn’t in quite the state that Corie and Paul’s is (plus, there’s an elevator rather than six flights of stairs) It was scary when I first moved though, I lived by myself so I didn’t know how to fill the time. It was a brand new building however, so things did break often–but on the bright side, I had a bathtub!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: The show’s title comes from Corie’s carefree attitude towards life, as she encourages her rather uptight business-minded newlywed husband to seize unconventional opportunities in life. Is that an attitude to which you yourself subscribe?
REGAN AYCOCK: To be honest, the biggest challenge that came with playing Corie was her energy. Having to pull her loveliness and energy was difficult, as I’m a bit more of a Paul in real life. I wish to be more like Corie, she just has so much fun no matter what she’s doing. What I do have in common with her though is I think with my heart first rather than my head, there are a few lines in act 1 where I think to myself “I don’t even need to act right now”.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: How much fun are you having being ‘married’ to your onscreen hubby, Evan Fenne?
REGAN AYCOCK: I’ve actually known Evan for a little bit now, we did a show together back in 2022, but hardly interacted, if at-all. It’s been great actually getting to connect with him, he’s a phenomenal actor, and an even sweeter guy. It’s nice having so much trust in a scene partner. Getting to be married is something that I’m having a lot of fun with, and it only got easier as myself and Evan got to be better friends. I can’t say enough good things about him, truly—he’s a class act.
Rapid Fire with BAREFOOT IN THE PARK’s Paul, Evan Fennel
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Who is Paul Bratter to you?
EVAN FENNE: To me, Paul Bratter is a guy who can’t fight the fact that he is a very particular and neat person, no matter how hard he tries. I think his whole life, he has been trying to prove that he can be “fun.” And he does like to have fun, just the Paul way.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Is there an aspect of Paul’s character that you’d like to incorporate into your own life?
EVAN FENNE: I really love the heart of the story being how two people who are so different can be so in love and value each other so much. Paul’s ability to love Corrie for all the ways she balances him out is one I’d like to exemplify in any of my relationships, not just romantic. Even when they’re fighting, I know Paul is saying everything with the implication that he still loves her.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: How familiar were you with the role prior to auditioning? AND…what was it about this show and this role in particular that prompted you to audition?
EVAN FENNE: I actually portrayed Paul in an acting class and read the play when I was at Belmont, so I was fairly familiar. After that, Paul became a dream role for me. I love Neil Simon’s sense of humor, and I immediately understood and loved Paul. When I saw that the Keeton was putting it up, I was immediately excited to audition. I’m very thankful that I was cast, and the experience has been amazing.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Quite often, it’s little details within the set decoration or props that prove the most interesting. Is there an aspect of the set that you enjoy and hope audiences take note of?
EVAN FENNE: The use of color in the set is particularly awesome to me. It’s the perfect amount and balance where it’s fun to look at but not too much. The space is also filled so well, and to be honest, it’s better decorated than my own apartment!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: When I chatted with Regan Aycock, I asked her about sharing the stage with you as young marrieds on stage, so I’ll ask you about having Regan as your ‘wife’? How is she as a scene partner?
EVAN FENNE: It’s been wonderful and a breeze to share the stage with Regan. We both have a lot of fun during the big argument because Paul and Corrie are trying to push each other’s buttons, while Evan and Regan are borderline trying to make each other break. She also cares greatly about making sure each of us feels comfortable and safe during scenes, for which I’m very grateful.
Rapid Fire with BAREFOOT IN THE PARK’s Ethel, Aleah Christian
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Keeton audience will no doubt recognize you, having portrayed Belinda Blair in their 2024 production of NOISES OFF. Loved you in that role, by the way! Now you’re playing Ethel Banks, aka Mother in BAREFOOT IN THE PARK. How would you describe Ethel?
ALEAH CHRISTIAN: Ethel is such a fun character to portray. She’s a devoted mom who’s spent most of her life doing what’s expected of her, but there’s this spark in her that hasn’t gone out—she just hasn’t had a reason to let it shine in a long time. Throughout the show, you see her get a little bolder, a little braver, and it’s really heartwarming. I love that she has more interest in her character than just “The Mom.” Ethel is rediscovering parts of herself.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What’s your favorite scene or bit of dialogue from the show?
ALEAH CHRISTIAN: There’s a scene where Ethel has just climbed all those infamous stairs and is trying so hard to act like she’s completely fine. The physical comedy is so relatable—like when you’re trying to look composed but your body is saying, “Nope!”
JHPENTERTAINMENT: If research serves, this isn’t your first time being directed by West, having starred as M’Lynn in a 2019 production of STEEL MAGNOLIAS under his direction. What is one aspect of West’s direction that you appreciate as an actress?
ALEAH CHRISTIAN: I love working with Lenny. He’s so intuitive and creates a space where actors feel supported but also challenged in the best way. He gives you the freedom to make bold choices, but he’s always there with a thoughtful note that somehow unlocks a deeper layer of the character. His timing is just spot on. He knows how to bring out the best in a cast. Lenny is selfless and meticulous in overseeing every detail. Honestly, I could go on… I am so grateful for the opportunity to work with him again!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Some of the show’s funniest scenes happen between Ethel and Victor Vilasco, the rather eccentric upstairs neighbor of Paul and Corie. In this production, Victor is played by Steve Mook. What’s been the best thing about sharing the stage with Steve?
ALEAH CHRISTIAN: Steve has been a joy to work with! He brings so much charm and spontaneity to Victor. We’ve had a blast finding that chemistry between our characters. We are still discovering moments. He’s one of those actors who keeps you on your toes in the best way, you never feel like you’re just going through the motions. He is a great scene partner and it’s been a lot of fun sharing the stage with Steve.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: At one point, playwright Neil Simon had four plays running in four Broadway theatre at the same time, BAREFOOT IN THE PARK being one of them. While that was during the mid-60s, his work is just as timeless, entertaining and funny today. Why do you think his work holds up so well?
ALEAH CHRISTIAN: Neil Simon’s writing is rooted in real people. Even with all the comedy, his characters feel familiar. They are flawed, funny, and trying to figure things out…just like the rest of us. His dialogue is so sharp, but also full of heart. You laugh because it’s funny, but also because you recognize yourself (or someone you know) in these characters. In essence, his work is timeless and relatable on so many levels.
Rapid Fire with BAREFOOT IN THE PARK director, Lenny West
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I understand this is your third time to direct BAREFOOT IN THE PARK. So, I gotta ask…What keeps you coming back to this particular work?
LENNY WEST: You are correct! This is indeed my third time in the director’s chair for this gem of show. BAREFOOT IN THE PARK is the very first play I ever directed, so it absolutely holds a special place in my heart and that’s certainly part of what keeps me coming back to it. Getting to check in with Paul, Corie, Mrs. Banks, Mr. Velasco & Harry Pepper every 10-ish years is like getting a warm hug from an old friend. I think it’s also a terrifically funny script. Most people will know Neil Simon from The Odd Couple, his most famous play, but I personally think Barefoot in the Park is his best. It’s story and the circumstances our characters find themselves in, while a bit exaggerated for comic effect of course, are pretty true to life and many people will recognize themselves in it. It’s one of the classic comedies of the American theater, and classics are classics for a reason. They deserve to be taken out, dusted off and revisited every now and then. Also, the opportunity just keeps presenting itself!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Having directed the show three times, some might think you simply just plug in the new cast from each company, so what it is about this piece that allows you to find new ideas as a director from production to production?
LENNY WEST: That’s a great question, and it comes down to primarily two things: First, my perspective and life experience has been different each time, so it’s impossible to not bring a bit of that to the project. 22-year-old-me saw the world and this play very differently from 34-year-old-me who sees things even more differently from (almost!) 45-year-old-me. I think a great work of art is one that you can revisit over and over and each time it will speak to you in a new way based on where you are on this crazy journey called life. While the bones of the play obviously stay the same and the truths at the center of the story remain, fresh nuances are revealed each time I come back to the play. The second thing is the performers I have been fortunate enough to work with each time. Each actor brings their own experience and interpretation and talent and those things of course will inform how they inhabit their roles As a director, I learned a long time ago to never ever try to squeeze a performer into a prior interpretation of the role. It never works! And what a gift it has been to see three very different groups of individuals bring this universal story to life! I’ve been incredibly lucky.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: BAREFOOT IN THE PARK marks your debut with The Keeton. How did directing this show for Keeton come about?
LENNY WEST: This opportunity sort of sought me out, actually. Nashville theater legend Linda Speir is a dear friend and one of The Keeton’s board members. She has been nudging me for a few years (sometimes gently, sometimes no so gently!) to come and work at The Keeton in some capacity, but the timing was never quite right and the right project hadn’t presented itself. Last spring after The Keeton’s new season was announced, Linda nudged again and the time and the project were both right, and one thing led to another and here we are!. And I’m glad she kept nudging! I’ve had a great time at The Keeton.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: The entirety of BAREFOOT IN THE PARK takes place in a relatively small fifth floor New York walkup. What are the challenges and advantages of directing, what is a single set piece?
LENNY WEST: Ordinarily, I’d say that a play with a single set is a huge advantage in that once it’s built and decorated, you’re essentially finished and can move on to making the staging and movement of the actors interesting and visually appealing, which admittedly can be a challenge on a static set. However, with Barefoot in the Park the conceit is that the first scene takes place the day that Corie & Paul move into their tiny apartment–so essentially an empty room–, and the next scene is four days later after furniture has arrived and after the room has been decorated and brought to full, colorful life. So, sure, it’s one single set, but there is a MAJOR scene change that must occur. No spoilers here as to how we accomplish it–to find out, you’ll just have to come see the show!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What do you hope audiences remember long after seeing The Keeton’s production of BAREFOOT IN THE PARK?
LENNY WEST: BAREFOOT IN THE PARK is first and foremost a delightful, often laugh-out-loud comedy with a huge heart, so I hope audiences will remember that they (hopefully!) had a great time watching the trials and tribulations of Corie & Paul’s first week of marriage. But Neil Simon–that old sneaky devil–doesn’t let us off that easily. The moral of story as I see it is that to make any kind of relationship successful, there must be compromise, there must be give and take, and everyone involved must be willing to take a small step outside of their comfort zone in order to see world from the other person’s perspective. We shouldn’t only seek to be understood but we must also seek to understand. We should see and appreciate and celebrate differences and eccentricities in others rather than finding fault with them. ….and if can do that, you just might find something beautiful. These things are necessary in order to really connect with another person, and in a world that is increasingly isolated and divided, we need connection now more than ever. That Neil Simon….he might’ve been on to something, eh?
—————
The Keeton’s BAREFOOT IN THE PARK opens Friday, April 11 and continues through Sunday, April 27 with 7pm shows Thursday through Saturday and a 2pm matinee on Sunday. Thursdays are Show Only nights (Show Only tickets are $30). As always, The Keeton’s dinner offering is a perfect compliment to their current show. For BAREFOOT, The Keeton is serving Dinner Salad, Pork Chop with Gravy, Mashed Potatoes, Green Beans, a Rolle and Apple Cobbler with Ice Cream. Dinner and Show tickets are $40 (plus a $2 fee) For Adults and $35 (plus $2 fee) for Children. For a slight uncharge, Salmon can be substituted as the main entree. For groups of 15 or more, The Keeton offers a group rate of $38 (plus $2 fee) per person. CLICK HERE for tickets.
Following BAREFOOT IN THE PARK, The Keeton will host their annual fundraising gala, A Night Under The Stars. Tickets to the event are $60. CLICK HERE for tickets or more information. Following the gala, The Keeton’s current season continues with COMPANY June 13-29. CLICK HERE for tickets and more information.
So you don’t miss out on upcoming shows at The Keeton Dinner Theatre, follow them on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.
Interested in coverage for your latest entertaining endeavor? Click the contact page and drop me a note. You can also follow JHP Entertainment on Instagram and Facebook. In the meantime, #GoSeeTheShow!