Described as “Monty Python meets Sherlock Holmes”, The Play That Goes Wrong is a guffaw-inducing, laugh-a-minute, play-within-a-play joy-ride of a farce that centers ‘round a fictional polytechnic school’s drama society as they present the whodunnit mystery, The Murder at Haversham Manor. Having taken London’s West End by storm, The Play That Goes Wrong is currently enjoying its Broadway debut run in New York while the touring company bumbles and stumbles across America on the show’s first US National Tour, Nashville and TPAC’s Jackson Hall being the tour’s current stop with shows thru Sunday, October 14.
From the moment patrons are handed their playbill as they enter the theatre to see a performance of The Play That Goes Wrong, it’s evident they aren’t in for an average run-of-the-mill night of theatre, for you see, even the program book seems to have had a bit of a printing mishap resulting in the cover graphic being printed slightly off-register. Then, as the audience settles into their seats, there’s a bit of a kerfuffle onstage as what appears to be tech crew members appear to be making last-minute adjustments to set pieces. Meanwhile, one of the stars of the show walks out into the audience introducing himself as the director and star while still others bustle about in search of a Duran Duran cd box set…and a dog named Winston. All this before the show technically starts.
From there, it’s two and a half-hours of pratfalls, missed cues, forgotten lines and face-hurting laughter. It’s like those clips of old Carol Burnett Show sketches in which one slight snicker amongst the actors results in an all-out uncontrollable laugh-riot for both the actors and the audience.
Reinforcing the show-within-a-show idea, a quick look at the playbill reveals two sets of information, one for The Murder at Haversham Manor, and one for The Play That Goes Wrong. The fictional bios for the drama society members, all in their touring debut, coincidentally, are hilarious and worth a read in their own right. Meanwhile, the actual cast bios reveal some very impressive credits, including at least two cast members making their return to Nashville, having previously starred in touring productions of other shows, as well as one cast member who previously appeared in the Broadway production of The Play That Goes Wrong.
Leading the cast as the aforementioned director and star of the the whodunnit is Evan Alexander Smith, who plays Chris Bean. In additional to Smith’s Bean being listed in the Murder program as director, he’s also credited as the show-within-a-show’s producer, prop maker, box office manager and about ten other behind-the-scenes crew titles. Oh, and Bean also plays Inspector Carter, who is called to Haversham to investigate a murder. As is the case when a director casts himself in a show (yes, it’s one of my actual theatrical pet peeves), wearing too many hats usually results in disaster. Smith seriousness as Bean is evident from the beginning, when Bean addresses the audience and in doing so, reveals some rather humorous facts about the company, including the budget-necessitating previous presentation of Cat (the obvious joke being they didn’t have the funds to present the better-known Cats). It them follows that Bean’s seriousness as Inspector Carter and the show’s director as the show goes wrong time and time again from the get, sets the hilarious pace for the inevitable unraveling of the show…and the cast.
With initial misplaced props and missed cues, Smith’s Bean barely flinches as the powers through, but when a later scene calls for him to find ledger tucked in the cushions of a chaise lounge…or should I say…chaise longue…but I digress….anyway, the ledger isn’t where it’s supposed to be and Bean’s boiling-point is reached, to hilarious result. As if they knew exactly what to do, an audience member shouts out, “It’s under the chaise lounge”. Smith’s Bean breaks the fourth wall, chastises the audience for laughing and suggests perhaps they’d be better suited to be at a Honky Tonk, or perhaps, The Grand Ole Opry– – -two Nashville-centric entertainment options – – -which, of course, only results in more laughter and thunderous applause from the audience for the clever inclusion of a bit of local flavor from the touring company. One joke, about Hamilton, however, might not play as well in Nashville as it does across the country, seeing as how Nashville audiences will have to wait another season for tickets to that hot item.
Smith as Bean is just the tip of the iceberg…YES, I use that reference purposely, because the show, with it’s cleverly choreographed and write mishaps appears to sink quicker than the Titanic, but to blissfully, purposeful results.
Scott Cote, last seen by TPAC audiences as Brother Jeremiah in last year’s national tour of Something Rotten, is hilarious as Dennis Tyde. His fictitious Murder cast bio indicates he’s new to acting, having only joined the Drama Society after failing tryouts in a number of sports. In Murder, Cote’s Dennis is cast as Perkins, the butler. I know what you’re thinking…and while I did indeed as Cote is the butler did it when I interviewed him for my most recent Rapid Fire 20 Q, I cannot include his response as a Spoiler Alert here. What I can tell you is Cote’s Dennis is the epitome of the newbie thespian. He garners his biggest laughs from the audience when he no-so-casually glances at his hands where he’s evidently scribbled certain words of dialogue he has trouble pronouncing, then proceeds to mispronounce them anyway.
Ned Noyes , who was part of Broadway’s The Play That Goes Wrong prior to being cast in the touring company, is scene-stealing as Max Bennett who plays Cecil Haversham, owner of the manor house in which the murder occurs. Early on, when Cecil goofs a line and gets a bigger response from the audience that had he executed the line perfectly, Noyes’ Bennett begins to over exaggerate his delivery as Cecil, thus receiving even bigger laughs. Being a huge fan of Lucille Ball (no secret to anyone who knows me), this reminded me of the classic comedy legend whenever her Lucy Ricardo character would goof onstage at Ricky’s nightclub. The bigger the audience response, the bigger the delivery of each subsequent line. My face truly began to hurt from laughing so much whoever Noyes was onstage opening night.
Peyton Crim portrays Robert Grove. His fictional bio references such roles as Lame Horse in Black Beauty and Dopey in Show White and The Tall Broad Gentleman. Crim’s Grove sees himself as one of the show’s more serious actors. in Murder, Grove is cast as Thomas Colleymoore, prime suspect in the murder of his sister’s intended, who’s got a bit of a secret himself. In spite of Grove’s serious nature, or perhaps because of it, the physical comedy his character endures as the set literally begins to fall apart, is all the more enjoyable for the audience. My companion for opening night in Nashville commented during one of Crim’s more physically demanding scenes that insurance for The Play That Goes Wrong must be astronomical. I suspect she’s right.
Brandon J. Ellis is subtly wonderful as sound tech, Trevor Watson. His fictional bio reveals he’s only part of The Murder at Haversham Manor to fulfill a requirement for an engineering course. During the entire show, Ellis’ Watson is seen to the left of the stage at his light and sound board. Frequently nodding off or otherwise distracted by his cellphone, Watson misses light and sound cues, only adding to the hilarity onstage, but nothing’s funnier than when Ellis’ Watson is forced on-stage to step into the role of Murder’s female lead when both she and the stage manager-unplanned understudy are knocked out cold.
Speaking of the female lead and the stage manger, Jamie Ann Romero and Angela Grovey portray those roles respectively. Romero plays Sandra Wilkinson. Wilkinson’s Murder bio indicates she’s the company’s most experienced member, having been with the company eleven seasons. Romero, as Wilkinson, plays Florence Colleymoore, the above-mentioned fiancee to the murder victim. Romero’s Wilkinson is played with diva-like disdain for her fellow cast mates, but when things go awry, Romero shines as she exhibits simply astonishing physicality.
Part of that physicality comes courtesy a bit of rivalry between Murder’s leading lady and the only other female in the company, Angela Grovey as Annie Twilloil, the company’s stage manager. Grovey, like her co-star, Cote, is also making a return to TPAC’s stage, having previously played Medda in the first national tour of Disney’s Newsies. As stage manger Annie, Grovey seems to be the glue that holds the company together. Annie’s fictional Murder bio backs this up, siting that after Murder, she’ll leave the company to intern with the Oregon Shakespeare Festival. Throughout the show Annie can be seen—much to her horror—racing onstage to grab a falling piece of the set or place a forgotten prop, but when the show’s leading lady gets knocked out, Annie gets a taste of the spotlight and even though she’s reading her lines from a binder, it’s obvious she’s enjoying her time in the spotlight, for when the leading lady reemerges its a battle of the Florences with both actresses reciting their lines in unison until they literally push each other out the set’s window. While these two have limited stage time, compared to some of the show’s other cast members, when they’re on…THEY ARE ON. When I chatted with Grovey for my recent Rapid Fire 20 Q, I asked her about her on-stage rivalry with Romero, and their backstage friendship. For her response, check out the interview via the hyperlink above.
Rounding out the cast is Yaegel T. Welch, as Jonathan Harris as murder victim, Charles Haversham. His fictitious bio reveals a recent career switch from model to actor, perfect for a character who’s dead to begin with. As the curtain rises on the show, Welch’s Harris isn’t quite on his mark, making it even funnier that the corpse is moving. When cast members step on his hand, he moves, eliciting uproarious laughter form the audience. Offering a bit of unintentional foreshadowing to Charles’ undead state, he frequently shows up throughout the play uttering a line whose time has not yet come and whenever he realizes his mistake, he quickly folds his arms across his chest a la Lily Munster and backs his way off the stage. Simply hilarious. Besides, he’s playing a character named Jonathan Harris, so you KNOW I gotta love that (what else did you think the JH in JHPEntertainment stood for?)
To say that’s the entire cast is a bit inaccurate, for you see, Nigel Hook’s set, which won the Tony Award for the show’s current Broadway run, is as much a character and integral part of the show as any of the actors. The ridiculously clever and technically intricate set mishaps—what with it’s falling wall sconces, crashing portraits, broken mantlepieces, combusting elevator and a collapsing second story study—enhance the slapstick, pratfalls and goofs throughout. While the dialogue and mishaps themselves would indeed be humorous to witness, thanks to a more-than clever story written by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, as directed by Matt DiCarlo, the added visual of the deterioration of the set as the cast themselves descend into disaster is amplified a thousand times by Hook’s brilliant set design and this company of actors who are secure enough in their comedic craft to make playing a troupe of inept thespians seem effortless.
While this review can only attempt to convey the unbridled hilarity, you truly must see it to fully appreciate the true brilliance of the show, its physical humor and the impeccably timed delivery. For a real testament to the show’s creative genius, just go up to anyone who’s seen The Show That Goes Wrong, and repeat lines like “I’m taking the stairs”, “She’s having an episode” or the simple words “ledger” and ‘cyanide”. The resulting grins, snickers and spontaneous laughter are proof positive The Show That Goes Wrong is indeed the show that goes oh so right as far as a great time enjoying a night out at the theatre is concerned.
The National Touring company of The Play That Goes Wrong continues at TPAC’s Jackson Hall with shows thru Sunday, October 14. Friday and Saturday evening performances at 8 p.m. There’s also a Saturday matinee at 2 p.m. and Sunday performances at 1 p.m. and 6:30 p.m. Tickets to The Play That Goes Wrong range in price from $30 to $90. CLICK HERE for tickets or more information.
Not in Nashville, but interested in seeing The Play That Goes Wrong? Follow the show on social media at the official The Play That Goes Wrong site HERE, or on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter.
Following The Play That Goes Wrong, TPAC’s current Broadway Season continues with a return engagement of The Phantom of The Opera, playing Jackson Hall October 24-November 4. CLICK HERE for tickets or for more information.
As always, if you are interested in coverage for your latest entertaining endeavor, simply click the contact page and drop me a note. You can also follow JHP Entertainment on Instagram and Facebook.
Cast as Marian/Robin Hood is Melinda Paul. Whether in literature, on the stage, screen or even in one of my personal favorite depictions, Walt Disney’s 1973 animated feature, Robin Hood has always been portrayed with a self-assured cleverness. Paul takes that characteristic and builds on it, playing both Robin and his fairer alter-ego, Marian with equal parts confidence and concern. While she indeed swashbuckles with the best of them, her gentler scenes with Mackenzie Smith’s Little John provide the oft-outlandish comedic tone of the play with some much-appreciated sweetness. Side Note: Who wouldn’t fall for Smith? That kindness. That accent…that kilt.