Jukebox musicals—a theatrical piece that features songs from one particular artist, era or genre—are hugely popular. Such shows as Mamma Mia, Jersey Boys and Smokey Joe’s Cafe frequently find their way among the favorites of local and regional theatre companies’ go-to offerings, but leave it to Chaffin’s Barn Dinner Theatre to reach a little deeper into the jukebox musical genre as they present Breaking Up Is Hard To Do, onstage at Chaffin’s from Thursday, February 6-29. If you’re like me, you may never have heard of this particular show which features the music of Neil Sedaka, as it tells a 1960s tale of Marge Gelman (played by Melissa Silengo) a young woman who, after being left at the alter, decides to take her best girlfriend Lois Warner (Jenny Norris) along on what would have been her honeymoon trip to the Catskills at the end of summer, where they encounter locals Del Delmonico, (Liam Searcy) a good looking up-and-coming crooner, his friend, Gabe Green (Curtis Reed) who just so happens to be the force behind his music, Harvey Feldman (Scott Stewart) a stand-up comedian and Esther Simowitz (Vicki White) the owner of a popular nightspot.The fact that Chaffin’s is presenting a show that’s completely new to me, coupled with the fact that once I began researching the music included, I realized I knew virtually all of the tunes (I just didn’t necessarily know they were penned by Sedaka) and I knew I had to chat with director Joy Tilley-Perryman and members of her cast for my latest Rapid Fire 20 Q.
——————————
Rapid Fire 20 Q with Breaking Up Is Hard To Do director and cast members
Rapid Fire with Breaking Up is Hard to Do director, Joy Tilley-Perryman
JHP: I understand the show takes place in The Catskills during the 60s, a little Dirty Dancing romance with a dose of Cyrano de Bergerac and even a tad Bye Bye Birdie…is that a fair assessment?
JOY TILLEY-PERRYMAN: That is a fair assessment, with a great deal of zippy zingers, some awesome dance lifts and juggling thrown in for good measure.
JHP: The Catskills, in their prime, seem like a dream vacation. What’s your favorite vacation spot?
JOY TILLEY-PERRYMAN: My favorite vacation spot is Kauai, Hawaii. It is paradise and it has been far too long since I have been to the Waimea Falls. It is the island that Elvis made famous in Blue Hawaii and the island that Hurricane Iniki almost wiped out in 1992. I love the rhythm of island time and the blissful energy of the Hawaiian islands. If you have never been, do yourself a favor and go!
JHP: I haven’t but it’s definitely on my To Do List. So, what is it about this show that makes it the perfect addition to Chaffin’s current season?
JOY TILLEY-PERRYMAN: This show is truly a love story for everyone. We have couples of all ages included here. And for people of a certain age (ie me), this music is so familiar and comfortable and just plain fun. Fun fact, I had a baton routine to Love Will Keep Us Together when I was 10 or 11 and if pressed, I can still remember parts of it. Just don’t ask me to do any double elbow rolls or two hand spins into an aerial release. I would fall and quite possibly break a hip these days.
JHP: What can you tell me about your cast?
JOY TILLEY-PERRYMAN: This cast is full of my loves and and also a fresh face making his Barn debut. I love working with Scott, Vicki, Jenny, Curtis and Melissa and have found working with Liam to be an absolute delight. You would be hard pressed to find 6 more beautiful voices. They just make me smile! Also, this show has tons of audience participation, so come on out and see if you are in Mrs. Futternick’s chair or Mr. Weinblatt’s seat or are you the lucky lady who gets to come on stage and be serenaded by Del.
Rapid Fire with Breaking Up Is Hard To Do choreographer and co-star, Curtis Reed
JHP: When I chatted with Joy, I noted a bit of a comparison in one of the show’s plots to Cyrano, in that your character Gabe Greene, is basically the guy behind the success of popular Catskills performer Del Delmonico, making you Cyrano to Liam’s Christian. Does that sound about right?
CURTIS REED: I believe so. Liam plays Del who is oozing with charm but in all actuality is not that nice. And he is also only pretending to like Marge to get to Marge’s father, who Del thinks is a big Music Manager. My character is the nerdy, behind-the-scenes type who pines for the girl who goes unnoticed by most, but who is number one in his eyes. Gabe has the passion and the heart for music, while Del only has the looks and the voice.
JHP: Speaking of Searcy, while this is his first Chaffin’s show, you two shared the stage during Studio Tenn’s recent mounting of Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, right?
CURTIS REED: This is Liam’s first Barn show and we are so excited to have him as part of this cast. I loved working with Liam on Joseph at Studio Tenn. He is a great performer and always willing to learn and better himself. I challenged him on a few dance moves both solo and with Jenny and he is a total team player.
JHP: As I mentioned in my intro, you’re not only playing Gabe Greene, but you’re also the show’s choreographer. The 60s were such a fun time for iconic dance moves, have you had fun incorporating some of them into the show?
CURTIS REED: You will definitely see some nods from Dirty Dancing and from a lot of the background singers/dancers of the DoWop groups that were popular in that time period. Super cute, nothing too crazy (except for Liam and Jenny’s fast-paced Stupid Cupid duet so be on the lookout for that one!)
JHP: What’s your favorite musical number in the show and why?
CURTIS REED: For me it’s a toss up. I love Laughter in the Rain because it’s the duet I share with Melissa’s Marge, where Gabe, in his own way, professes his affection for her. It’s super touching and still has that nerdy 16 Candles vibe that is so heartwarming. My other favorite is the only number in the entire show where you hear all six actors at once and that is the finale, Love Will Keep Us Together. I mean how can you not love that feel-good song made popular by The Captain and Tennille?! I’m almost certain we will have audience members singing along with us throughout the show with so many memorable songs by Neil Sedaka!
Rapid Fire with Breaking Up Is Hard To Do’s Harvey, Scott Stewart
JHP: How would you describe Harvey Feldman?
SCOTT STEWART: Harvey is a veteran comic and long time performer at a Catskills resort in The Borscht Belt. His roots are in Vaudeville. Harvey still loves what he does but is lonely- and ready to open up about it.
JHP: What’s your favorite aspect of playing Harvey?
SCOTT STEWART:
My father had a lot of comedy albums and I grew up listening to the likes of Stiller & Meara, Mel Brooks, Carl Reiner, Fanny Brice, etc… many whom started in the Catskills. To get to pretend to be among those in a blast! And I’ve always been intrigued by the whole Catskills era of America. Getting to spend an entire summer in the mountains playing?! Wow!
JHP: The show features an all-Neil Sedaka songbook. Would you say you were a fan of his music prior to being cast in this show?
SCOTT STEWART: I am a fan of Neil Sedaka! I really didn’t learn who he was til, as a preteen, I heard The Captain & Tennille sing Love Will Keep Us Together and in the fade out of that song they sing “Sedaka is back”. I think it was Casey Kasem that explained who that was one week, and then I started to learn more about him. But this show has some songs with which I was not familiar.
JHP: As Harvey, you share scenes with Vicki White’s Esther. You’ve done several shows together. How much fun is she as a co-star?
SCOTT STEWART: Oh man, she is the best! Vicki has a unique way of rehearsing her characters and she puts so much thought into them, but it’s often not til late in the process when I see what she’s doing, and understand how to interact and play with her character. I love it! Keeps me from getting lazy.
Rapid Fire with Breaking Up Is Hard To Do’s Esther, Vicki White
JHP: What is your favorite aspect of playing Esther?
VICKI WHITE: Nothing keeps Esther down. She is fun, feisty, and a survivor.
JHP: When I chatted with Scott, I mentioned that you two share scenes. You’ve done a few shows together, right? Isn’t he just fantastic?
VICKI WHITE: Yes! I am lucky enough to have done many shows with the talented Scott Stewart. He is funny, down to earth, and has a beautiful voice. This has been my first opportunity to play opposite of Scott as a romantic interest and it has been a blast!
JHP: The 60s, the Catskills…if you could go back in time and experience that in real life, what do you think you’d enjoy most?
VICKI WHITE: Fancy clothes and cocktails. Everything was such an event, from the different activities to dinner and shows. They made a vacation last an entire summer. I am a huge fan of Mrs. Maisel and Dirty Dancing. I would LOVE to time travel with my family for a vacation in the Catskills!
JHP: Looking at the songs included in the show, I gotta admit, even though I have always loved The Captain and Tennille’s Love Will Keep Us Together, I didn’t realize it was a Neil Sedaka song. (In case you’re keeping up, yes, that makes four for four with mention of this particular tune, but I digress) Are there any songs in the show you were surprised to learn he had written?
VICKI WHITE: I was so surprised to find out that he had written Where the Boys Are. I knew it as this iconic song from the sixties that I had always associated with Connie Francis.
Rapid Fire with Breaking Up Is Hard To Do’s Lois, Jenny Norris
JHP: You play Lois Warner. How is the character most like yourself?
JENNY NORRIS: She is loyal and would do anything for those she loves. I would say those are two big parts of who I am.
JHP: As Lois, you’re best pals with Marge Gelman played by Melissa Silengo. Marge has been left at the altar and decided to bring her bestie Lois on the honeymoon instead. What’s the advantage of taking a girlfriend on your honeymoon?
JENNY NORRIS: Having a shopping buddy!
JHP: Chaffin’s resident costumer, Miariam Creighton is providing the wardrobe for the show. What’s your favorite 60s aesthetic as seen in the show, whether it be part of Lois’ wardrobe or that of one of your co-stars?
JENNY NORRIS: I have enjoyed the high waisted look in shorts and pants for ladies. It has inspired several of my recent Poshmark purchases. Plus big volume hair is always a favorite of mine!
JHP: Sedaka’s titular lyrics suggest that reconciliation is the solution. What do you think?
JENNY NORRIS: Well although he says breaking up is hard to do, I say sometimes being with the wrong one is harder. You’ll have to come see if Marge realizes it or not!
——————————
As Norris suggests, audience members will have their chance to see how Marge deals with her breakup as Breaking Up Is Hard To Do plays Chaffin’s Barn Dinner Theatre Thursday, February 6 thru Saturday, February 29. CLICK HERE or call 615.646.9977 for reservations. Thursday matinees begin at 12 noon (doors at 11a.m.), while Thursday, Friday and Saturday evening performances begin at 7:30p.m. (doors at 5:30). Sunday matinees begin at 2 p.m. (with doors at noon for lunch service.
Thursday matinee tickets are $20 for show only or $28.50 for show and a Box Lunch. Evening show tickets are $18 for children 12 and under, $25 for youth/students and $47 for adults.
Of course, being Chaffin’s Barn Dinner Theatre, they also offer a full buffet option or a la carte menu items for their evening and Sunday lunch matinee performances. Chaffin’s delicious buffet, featuring a choice of entrees (including a veggie option), and a number of side items is available for an additional $15.95, while the ‘a la carte menu items (also quite tastily) range in price from $6.95 to $10.95. Plus there’s a wide array of dessert options to choose from $2.50 to $5.00. CLICK HERE to check out the menu.
On Friday, February 14, Chaffin’s will host a special Valentine’s Day performance of Breaking Up Is Hard To Do which will feature a special Valentine’s Day menu and three ticket level options. First, for $150 per couple, patrons can enjoy the show, buffet dinner, a bottle of champaign or sparkling cider, a special dessert plate with chocolate strawberries and cheesecake, a rose for that special someone and a chance to win some fabulous prizes. For $220, you can secure a private four-top table for two, plus all of the above-listed amenities. For $330, two couples can enjoy a private six-top table for four with all the above amenities. CLICK HERE to view the special Valentine’s Day Menu. Please call the box office to book these special reservations.
To keep up with the latest from Chaffin’s Barn Dinner Theatre, find them online at ChaffinsBarnTheatre.com, ’like’ them on Facebook and follow them on Instagram and Twitter.
If you’ve enjoyed this edition of Rapid Fire, CLICK HERE to check out previous conversations. Interested in coverage for your latest entertaining endeavor? Click the contact page and drop me a note. You can also follow JHP Entertainment on Instagram and Facebook.
While many in the Nashville area (myself among them) associate the iconic singer and the nearly-equally beloved musical with local mega-talent Mandy Barnett, who’s many performances in the role are as near to seeing Cline herself as anyone can get, director Benji Kern and star Chambers make wise choices in the way Chambers presents Cline. While Barnett mystifyingly embodies the icon, so much so, you might begin to believe in reincarnation, Chambers makes her turn as Cline her own, and in doing so, putting the emphasis on both jukebox and musical, offering audiences something between a tribute show and a modern take on the esteemed theatrical piece and the woman for whom the show is named.
