
Lithium & Xanax and All of My Friends, a thought-provoking play centering ‘round a young gay man struggling to finish his long-promised novel while simultaneously dealing with self-doubt and cerebral upheaval is the latest work from Nashville-based playwright, Robert Coles. Quite the departure from his most recent production, the southern comedy Aunt Sally’s Wild Ride, which recently wrapped a sold out run in Nashville.
Having first been introduced by way of a Zoom reading during the COVID-19 pandemic, Lithium & Xanax and All of My Friends enjoyed a successful workshop in New York in August 2024. Now comes time for a fully fleshed-out production as Brand Spankin’ New Theatre presents the World Premiere production of Coles’ Lithium & Xanax & All of My Friends at the Darkhorse Theatre beginning Friday, October 4 and continuing through Saturday, October 12.
As the cast and crew ready the piece for their Music City opening night, I recently had the opportunity to pose a few questions to the show’s director, Bradley Moore and cast members Payton Justice and Taryn Pray for my latest Rapid Fire Q&A interview in an effort to get a little insight into the show. What follows are those conversations.
—————
Rapid Fire 10Q with Director and Cast of Lithium & Xanax & All of My Friends
Rapid Fire Q&A with Lithium & Xanax & All of My Friends lead actor, Payton Justice
JHPENTERTAINMENT: How would you describe Adam, the character you play in Lithium & Xanax & All of My Friends?
PAYTON JUSTICE: Adam’s a young writer who’s indecisive, headstrong, and a bit neurotic. Honestly, just a lovable mess just trying to figure things out. He’s been through a lot—losing his dad, the trauma of conversion therapy, dealing with manic depression, and having to manage a lot of guilt from his past mistakes. He spends a lot of time in his own head, which really trips him up.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: The subject matter of the work is some pretty heady stuff. How do you prepare for the intensity of the scenes? AND…what’s your favorite way to decompress after such intense work?
PAYTON JUSTICE: It gets intense for sure. I try to remind myself of my own personal experiences to find the emotions he’d be feeling. I try to remember a similar conversation or conflict, and remind myself of how that felt or something that was said.
Bradley Moore’s been awesome in helping me fine-tune Adam’s intentions. Truly a fantastic director. The cast has been awesome too. They push me through tough moments, and sometimes their choices completely change how I see a scene, which is really cool.
To decompress, I try to leave the work in the rehearsal room or at the theater. My cats and video games definitely help me unwind too.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: While Adam is aware of his shortcomings, he doesn’t seem to know how to move past them. Heck, I can totally relate myself. Has exploring this aspect of the character motivated you to move full-steam ahead in any aspect of your own life?
PAYTON JUSTICE: Yeah, totally. Playing Adam has been a bit of a wake-up call. I moved to Nashville at the beginning of 2020, right before everything went crazy, and it’s taken time to find my rhythm. I’m really feeling ready to focus in on acting and let go of all the things that don’t matter in the bigger picture.
Rapid Fire Q&A with Lithium & Xanax & All of My Friends cast member Taryn Pray
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What can you tell me about Mom, the character you play in Lithium & Xanax & All of My Friends?
TARYN PRAY: What I love about this role is yes, the main character I play is “Mom,” but I also play a few flashback and ancillary characters as well – which is so much fun as an actor! There is a lot of comedy in the other characters that I play, and then I get to be this very complex character of “Mom,” as she is trying to navigate her broken relationship with her son in his darkest moment. It is very compelling because you understand her perspective as well as Adam’s – not one person is to blame. Before I read this play, I thought the mother might be the villain in this story, but she is not. Is she flawed? Absolutely. Did she make some mistakes? Yes. But what is really beautiful to me is that they come to understand each other and can move forward.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I understand the character of Mom wasn’t even really a character in the earlier iteration of the play, only a ‘flashback’ as played by another cast member, but following the recent NYC workshop of the piece, the playwright revised the script and fleshed out Mom as a full character. That said, how excited are you to be bringing this character to life on stage for the first time anywhere?
TARYN PRAY: I absolutely love acting in new works! It’s really exciting to originate a role and bring your own take, without any reference to how other actors have performed it. Also knowing that this play is very much rooted in the playwright’s own life story, I feel a tremendous amount of responsibility and honor in playing this role. I am thrilled that this character was expanded as a result of the workshop, and love seeing the nuance in her complicated relationship with Adam.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: From what your director told me, you two had sort of worked together previously…I say sort of because during the pandemic, you were part of a couple of Bradley Moore’s The Big Read Zoom events, in which he presented readings of some iconic film scripts as performed by area actors. I gotta tell you, those readings were such a blessing to the theatre community as they allowed us to connect—though virtually—during a time when theatre was so missed. Now you’re working with Bradley face-to-face and in person as your director, so I gotta ask..how has the experience been so far and what do you appreciate most about Bradley as a director?
TARYN PRAY: Oh my goodness, yes! I met Bradley for the first time virtually, and those readings truly were such a bright light in a dark time. Having the opportunity to perform when we were all stuck at home was definitely a blessing. And now getting to work with him in this play has been an incredible experience. What I love about Bradley is he has such a clear vision as a Director; he has brought out so much from the cast as we are developing these characters, while still giving us space to make them our own, and he has created some truly beautiful imagery on stage. He really thinks through and has a purpose in all the little details he gives in his direction, and I’m just so excited for people to see it. Also, he’s just a blast to work with 😉
Rapid Fire with Lithium & Xanax & All of My Friends director, Bradley Moore
JHPENTERTAINMENT: How did you come to direct Lithium & Xanax & All of My Friends?
BRADLEY MOORE: I was actually lucky enough to perform in the first reading of this play on Zoom & FB Live way back in the Covid-y days of 2020. I was totally honored when the playwright, Robert M. Coles, reached out to me earlier this year and told me he had been working on the script and wanted me to direct the world premiere of the show. I even spent some time in NYC this summer observing the workshop of the play, where some things changed and so much subtext was explored. It has been a wonderful journey from my first connection to the piece to where we are today. The show is definitely ready for its Nashville maiden voyage, especially with this insanely talented cast.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What can you tell me about your cast?
BRADLEY MOORE: They are bananas. I have not directed a show in Nashville in five years; it was so cool to have auditions for this show and see that the talent in Nashville is still just as incredible as it has always been. This cast is filled with six dynamic artists who take risks, make strong choices, challenge themselves, challenge me, crave collaboration, exude passion, and blow me out of the water every single day with their insane talent. Not to mention, each and every one of them are kind and empathetic humans who just love what they do. I love the family we have built these past five weeks. And their connections and chemistry really come out on stage and through these complex characters they have created.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You’ve not just assembled a talented cast, but you’ve surrounded yourself with a who’s who crew, among them, Cat Eberwine as your costumer. When does the play take place and how important is wardrobe in completing the look and feel of the show?
BRADLEY MOORE: This play takes place in 2022, so basically, the recent past. Costumes should always enhance the characters and assist in bringing them to life. We made more simplistic choices with the costumes, but the choices really do help to define these characters. As a director, I love some subtle Easter eggs hidden throughout the show. We definitely achieve that with this show through the set and costumes. It helps to keep production elements fresh and exciting, plus adds a layer of intrigue to the whole experience. This show is a journey, not just for the characters, but the audience too. Our costume and set choices are designed to really enhance that circumstance. I am so fortunate to have had Cat Eberwine as our Costume Czar and Jaymes Campbell as our Set Magician. These are two people who know me well, know my process and style, and really just knocked it out of the park. We could not have done this show without them. Also, big shoutout to Mary Hankins for always being an incredible stage manager, Robert Allen for his beautiful lighting, and Josiah Kareck for understudying every single role. Truly, surrounded by the best, on and off-stage.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What do you hope audiences come away thinking about long after seeing Lithium & Xanax and All of My Friends?
BRADLEY MOORE: As a director, I always say — if the audience walks away feeling something, then we have done our job. However, it is impossible for us to always know what the audience will feel. With a play like Lithium, I believe people’s life experiences will inform what they take away from this show. The play is funny, yet beautifully heavy and impactful. I don’t think it is possible to sit through this 75 minute show and not feel a single thing; in fact, I think it is more likely that someone watching will experience all the feels. It is a rollercoaster ride, so just buckle in and get ready to take a journey. I am excited to see the feedback we get from this tremendous piece that Robert gifted us.
—————
Brand Spankin’ New Theatre’s World Premiere production of Lithium & Xanax and All of My Friends kicks off Friday night, October 4 at the Darkhorse Theatre (4610 Charlotte Ave, Nashville, TN 37209). Tickets are $20 and can be purchased HERE. The show runs thru Saturday, October 12. Performance schedule is as follows: Opening Night, Friday, October 4 at 7:30p.m. (There’s a Show+Opening Night Party ticket option available for $40), Saturday, October 5 at 7:30p.m., Sunday, October 6 at 2:30p.m., Tuesday, October 8 at 7:30p.m., Thursday, October 10 at 7:30p.m. (Thursday’s performances offers a special 2-for-1 ticket price), and Friday & Saturday, October 11 & 12 at 7:30p.m. CLICK HERE for more info. Check out Brand Spankin’ New Theatre‘s Official Site HERE or follow them on Facebook.
As always, if you wanna follow JHPEntertainment to find out who I’m chatting with for my next Rapid Fire Q&A, or for my take on the latest local and national theatre, music and movie offerings, find us at JHPEntertainment on Facebook, JHPEntertainment on Instagram and JHPEntertainment on Twitter. Got an event or show we should know about, drop us a line at the Contact tab. Till then, #GoSeeTheShow!

Rapid Fire with Waitress star, Sarah Aili
JHPENTERTAINMENT:
Rapid Fire with Waitress co-star, Piper Jones
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I saw on your Facebook that you, in another media moment promoting Waitress, cited your Mama’s Chess Pie as your all-time favorite. Heck, I think you and I might hold the record for most Chess Pie-related Facebook posts. So, a two-parter… 1) What is it about your Mama’s Chess Pie? AND…2) I think you might like my Mama’s Chess Pie, too, so when are we gonna trade recipes?
Rapid Fire with Waitress co-star, Annabelle Fox
JHPENTERTAINMENT:
Rapid Fire with Waitress director, Lauren Shouse
__________
Where character portrayal is concerned, Clue could be considered a bit of a theatrical anomaly. Typically actors stepping into roles made famous by others are charged with making the character their own, but Clue, a true farce, almost demands that the company present the characters pretty much as those who portrayed the roles in the film had done. That’s not to discredit the actors in any way, but to thank them for brilliantly recreating moments and actions of the film to glorious life live on stage.
John Shartzer’s Mr. Green (the Michael McKean role in the film) is the scene stealer of the show. With precise comedic timing, hilariously deadpan reactions and borderline acrobatic slapstick movement, Shartzer is suspect Number 1 is so many ways.

RAPID FIRE WITH AN IDEAL HUSBAND’s SIR ROBERT CHILTERN, ANDREW GATELEY
RAPID FIRE WITH AN IDEAL HUSBAND’s LADY CAVERSHAM, ANN STREET-KAVANAGH
RAPID FIRE WITH ERIN GRACE BAILEY, PRODUCER AND CO-STAR OF AN IDEAL HUSBAND
RAPID FIRE WITH AN IDEAL HUSBAND DIRECTOR, EVAN FENNE
Leading the cast in the role of George will be David Shannon. Mr. Shannon is an Irish actor often called “Ireland’s Greatest Showman.” He has performed many iconic stage roles in London’s West End and beyond, including The Phantom of the Opera, Valjean in Les Miserables, Miss Trunchbull in Matilda, and Sweeney in Sweeney Todd. He played Kevin T in the original London company and North American tour of Come From Away, and he was nominated for an Olivier Award for his performance in The Beautiful Game. Critics throughout the UK have heralded Mr. Shannon, calling him “…compellingly intense and beautifully voiced,” and “truly one of West End’s finest.” In addition to his theatrical work, he sings with some of the world’s leading orchestras.
In the role of George’s lover Dot will be Olivier Award-winning actress Laura Michelle Kelly. Ms. Kelly is best known as the original Mary Poppins in the world premiere of Disney’s Mary Poppins, a role she played both on Broadway and the West End, a performance the London Evening Standard said was, “nothing short of magical.” Her other critically lauded roles include Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady on the West End, which was described as a “tour de force” by the Evening Standard; and Sylvia Llewelyn Davies in Finding Neverland on Broadway, where New York critics said she brought “a radiant presence and a voice of pure enchantment. Ms. Kelly has played a host of other well-known roles in London, including Eponine in Les Miserables, Sophie in Mamma Mia, and Belle in Beauty and the Beast. Her other Broadway/NY shows include Fiddler on the Roof and the Encore’s production of Me and My Girl. She also was seen in the film version of Sweeney Todd as The Beggar Woman.
RAPID FIRE WITH THE BEAUTY QUEEN OF LEENANE’s MAG, CAT EBERWINE
RAPID FIRE WITH THE BEAUTY QUEEN OF LEENANE’s MAUREEN, LINDSEY PATRICK-WRIGHT
RAPID FIRE WITH HAIRSPRAY’s LINK LARKIN, SKYLER SHIELDS
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Prior to being cast as Link, you spent some time at sea…as a cast member of Saturday Night Fever aboard Royal Caribbean cruise lines. What was the best part of your time with that show and life afloat?
RAPID FIRE WITH HAIRSPRAY’s LITTLE INEZ, KAILA SYMONE CROWDER
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Speaking of your home state, Hairspray’s costume designer, William Ivy Long hails from Raleigh, North Caroline. He’s designed costumes for more than 60 Broadway show, having won the Tony for Hairspray in 2003. Do you have a favorite costume in the show, whether it be your’s or that of one of your co-stars?
RAPID FIRE WITH HAIRSPRAY’s VELMA VON TUSSLE, SARAH HAYES
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Again, while doing my homework prior to our chat, I fell down the proverbial Velma Von Tussle internet rabbit hole where I saw that fabulous Velma has an entry on Villains Wiki!!! So, a two-part question…1) How much fun are you having playing Velma and 2) Why is she NOT a villain?
RAPID FIRE WITH HAIRSPRAY’s PENNY PINGLETON, SCARLETT JACQUES
JHPENTERTAINMENT:

RAPID FIRE WITH FROZEN’s OLAF, JEREMY DAVIS
RAPID FIRE Q&A WITH FROZEN’s KRISTOFF, NICHOLAS EDWARDS

RAPID FIRE WITH YES! THE MUSICAL’s MISTER JIMMY, BRADLEY GALE
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Prior to saying YES!, you’ve enjoyed success on stage as part of the original company of Chicago’s The Book of Mormon, as well as numerous theatrical productions right here in Nashville, including roles in Beauty and the Beast, Avenue Q and Evita. How does being part of the World Premiere company of YES! compare?
RAPID FIRE WITH YES! THE MUSICAL’s ASHLEY, MAYA KAEMPF
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I understand part of your creative process in getting into your current character often involves creating a playlist of songs you think that character might listen to. What’s on Ashley’s playlist?
RAPID FIRE WITH YES! THE MUSICAL’s LINDA, ERIN McCRACKEN
JHPENTERTAINMENT: A quick perusal of your social media revealed that you said Yes just over a year ago! That dress was gorgeous, by the way. So, I’m guessing if any of the cast can relate to the trials and tribulations of the subject at hand, it’s you. How many dresses did you look at before you found the perfect one?
RAPID FIRE WITH
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I have to admit, of the character shots photographed by the always brilliant MA2LA, your Kayley image is my favorite! Did you enjoy your photoshoot day, and would you wear Kayley’s fit IRL?
For The Keeton’s presentation, co-directors Maguire and Gray have enlisted a great mix of newcomers and seasoned performers including
Now, back to the show…From the character’s initial entrance, Lloyd offers the first broken fourth wall as he stops the action on stage when one of the actors misses a prop cue. Carmichael’s Lloyd bellows from the audience and the fun begins. The actress Lloyd chastises for missing her cue is none other than Ann Street-Kavanagh, as middle-aged actress Dotty Otley, who’s playing the housekeeper in the show-within-a show. Street-Kavanagh is perfect for the role of Dotty as she’s never better than when she’s playing it a bit confused and daft. Like Lloyd, Dotty is also embroiled in a love triangle. All Dotty’s Nothing On character wants to do is put her feet up and enjoy the the telly. Oh, and did I mention she enjoys a snack of sardines? Worth noting, since a plate of the fishy snacks result in much of the show’s hilarity when left about, or taken off, cluing the other visitors in Nothing On that they’re not alone in the house.