A genuine life-long fan of spooky stories and horror movies,—seriously, Barnabas Collins, The Bell Witch and Michael Myers are among my favorite childhood memories. So when I heard Act 1 was presenting an original tale or terror, The Nighmarium Incident, written and directed by Eric Butler as a pre-Halloween offering at Darkhorse Theatre, I was all in.
Stage manager Katie Veglio, lighting designer Kristen Dubois and sound designer Kaitlin Barnett have created a ghoulishly perfect 1980s-era set that immediately put me in mind of Frankenstein’s lab, or, perhaps more accurately, the set of Sir Cecil Creep’s Creature Feature, a weekly Saturday night horror movie presentation—a Nashville television staple from my youth.
As the Nightmarium commences we are introduced to Maureen Henson (Natalie Stone) hosting W-KIL—gotta love those morbid call letters—Channel 9’s schlocky Friday night horror presentation, The Nightmarium Creature Double Feature as Mistress Twilight. It is quickly revealed that Maureen is simply biding her time as the Elvira wannabe while she patiently waits a more serious gig as co-anchor of the station’s evening news. Stone plays the duality of Maureen/Mistress Twilight with ease, vamping it up as the cheeky horror hostess, while alternately exploring Maureen’s career-driven seriousness.
As Mistress Twilight, Stone’s Maureen is surrounded by a perfectly stereotypical cast of characters including Jarvis Bynum as Maureen’s husband Wesley, who appears on the show-within-a-show as Papa Moreaux, a voodoo priest. Bynum, too manages to differentiate between the two characters he plays, presenting Wesley a devoted husband to Maureen, then switching gears to portray the creepy Papa Moreaux.
There’s also Beth Henderson as Dale, Channel 9’s mild-mannered weatherman who doubles on the horror fest as Dr. Solomon Wretch. In part because Henderson is playing Dale, which, given the unisex nature of the character’s name, could be a man or a woman, she’s a scene-stealer from the start. Whether the playwright originally envisioned Dale as a man or not is unclear, especially considering the inclusion of more than a few punchlines aimed directly at Dale’s masculinity. Nonetheless, Dale ends up being one of the best parts of the show thanks to Henderson’s comedic timing and her ability to deliver her lines with conviction, in spite of the silliness of the show.
While they spend the majority of the play hidden behind two Voodoo hand-puppets, Tori Simpson and Elizabeth Turner provide the show with many laughs throughout.
TJ Koomen is featured as the TV show’s technical director, Sam, offering up equal parts Alan Brady and Rob Petrie as the harried director who also has a bit of a soft side for his colleague Maureen.
Steven Kraski is perfectly weird as Luke the station’s custodian who dreams of making the leap from waaaay behind the scenes to front and center as one of the horror show’s cast members. He plays the creep factor so well in fact, I wasn’t convinced till the very end that all the trouble wasn’t simply Luke’s elaborate audition gone awry.
Stealing every single scene he’s in is Joseph Hudson as The Nightmarium’s cameraman, Joe. Hudson’s Joe is the good ole boy to end all good ole boys. Having grown up i a relatively small country town just west of Nashville, I definitely know the type and Hudson has it down to a science, rising above the predictable to riotous results.
Rounding out the show-within-a-show cast are Emmanuelle Loyer as Floor Manager Rhonda, Alyssa Borg as Sherri Peterson, the stations new seemingly vapid anchorwoman, Maureen’s main obstacle in her pursuit of being an news anchor and Matt Smith as Bill Haig, the station’s star anchor. Smith, always a joy to watch onstage, is another reason this show works. Dressed in wardrobe courtesy costumer Brooklyn Hughes reminiscent The Mary Tyler Moore Show’s self-important anchor, Ted Baxter, as played by Ted Knight or Will Ferrell’s Anchorman, Ron Burgundy—with an ego and toupee to match, Smith elicits laughter simply by standing there.
While the plot gets as murky as The Munsters’ moat…the infighting and interpersonal relationships between Maureen, her horror show co-stars and crew and her rivals at the news desk…plus the real plot of The Nightmarium Incident, when an accidental incantation brings murder and mayhem to the station…all in all, The Nightmarium Incident provides more than enough laughs, and a few frights, the perfect precursor to Halloween. With only an all-too-brief two-week run, here’s hoping Music City gets another chance to visit W-KIL and The Nightmarium Incident next season.
Act 1’s The Nightmarium Incident concludes its run with one final show Saturday, November 19 at 7:30p.m. CLICK HERE to purchase tickets in advance for $15, or purchase them at the door for $18.
Up next at Act 1 is playwright Lisa Loomer’s Distracted directed by Elizabeth Hayes, on stage November 15-17 and 21-23. CLICK HERE for more information.
To keep up with Act 1, follow them on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter.