The Keeton’s upcoming production of Come From Away (on stage August 14-30) brings the extraordinary true story of the 7,000 passengers who found themselves stranded in Gander, Newfoundland, following the events of September 11, 2001, to the stage in a celebration of compassion, community, resilience and kindness. For this JHPEntertainment Rapid Fire 20Q, we go behind the scenes with director Susan Walsworth and three members of the cast,–Melissa Silengo, Justin Tinker and Jason Scott–as they talk about returning to The Keeton, bringing real-life people to the stage, the unique challenges of Come From Away, aviation, friendship, finding the heart of a character and, ultimately, why this story continues to resonate.
———-
RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH CAST MEMBERS AND DIRECTOR OF THE KEETON’s COME FROM AWAY
RAPID FIRE WITH COME FROM AWAY‘s BEVERLY, MELISSA SILENGO
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You’ve played everything from Maria in The Sound of Music to Sister Mary Amnesia in Nunsense. What excited you most about taking on Beverly, Annette, and your other roles in Come From Away?
MELISSA SILENGO: I generally enjoy playing characters who are based on real-life people, so I was especially excited to take on multiple real-life people in this show. Beverly Bass is an inspiring woman who made her way in a man’s world with dedication and her love of flying. Annette is an amalgamation of multiple real-life people, so I have enjoyed the freedom to make her my own and lean into the character description of her as “a school teacher… with an active fantasy life.” The range of characters that each actor plays is one of the things that makes this show such a joy to interpret and to watch.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: After taking a few years away from the stage, what made this the perfect production to return with?
MELISSA SILENGO: The beautiful story and characters made this a great come-back production for me. The way the show is written makes it a challenge for everyone involved, and I have truly enjoyed dusting off many old skills and tricks of the trade to find my way through this process. The ensemble nature of the production and the people in our amazing cast and team have made this a very meaningful experience for me, and I am so thankful to be back in theatre.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: As you mentioned, Beverly is based on a real person. Her story is both inspiring and heartbreaking. What has it meant to step into her shoes?
MELISSA SILENGO: Stepping into the shoes of Beverly Bass is a huge honor and responsibility. I hope she would agree that her role in the events surrounding September 11th in Gander, Newfoundland was to provide some reassurance for her passengers in a time of complete uncertainty. Her strength, clarity of purpose, passion for aviation, communication skills, and earnest concern for her passengers made her the perfect pilot to handle this type of emergency situation. I hope I can convey at least some of those qualities and give her story the respect it deserves.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You’ve performed at several theaters across Middle Tennessee. What keeps bringing you back to The Keeton?
MELISSA SILENGO: The Keeton feels like my home theater, partly because it is close to my house, so that keeps me coming back. I am glad that people I have worked with over the years, like Donna and Kevin Driver, are still there continuing to keep the theater going. And one perk of doing shows at the Keeton is rehearsing on the same stage where you will perform. I have learned a lot performing at the Keeton over the years, and it feels nice to be back.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: If someone has never seen Come From Away, what’s the one thing you’d tell them before the lights go down?
MELISSA SILENGO: Can I say two things? Come From Away is a telling of multiple stories at once, so be prepared for the actors to change characters quickly and frequently. But more importantly, be prepared to remember your own experience of 9/11 and connect it with the story of a small town community caring for people from around the world in a show of true human spirit.
RAPID FIRE WITH COME FROM AWAY‘s KEVIN T., JASON SCOTT
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I understand that since your last Keeton production, you’ve become a flight instructor. Has that unique perspective made working on this show even more personal?
JASON SCOTT: Absolutely! This show is a perfect marriage of two of my biggest passions, and I couldn’t have asked for a better production to bring me back to the stage.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Kevin T. experiences one of the musical’s most moving emotional journeys. What have you discovered about him (and yourself) during rehearsals?
JASON SCOTT: It has been so interesting to play with the relative joy that Kevin tries to maintain even in the midst of such a tragic event. He refused to let the sadness consume him, and I’ve definitely found inspiration for myself in his story.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Between theater and aviation, storytelling and flying both require trust. Have you found any other surprising similarities between the two?
JASON SCOTT: I have long felt that my theatrical background was so useful in learning how to fly. There’s a lot of memorization involved, the ability to “improv” and react to things quickly, the ability to do the same sequence of “steps” on repeat, and so much more.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Is there a particular musical number or scene that really resonates with you, whether your’s or one you witness by way of your fellow cast mates?
JASON SCOTT: Well I think the obvious answer is “Me and the Sky”, so I’m going to add a second one. I truly think one of the moments that will resonates with me, and with most people who were around when it happened, is seeing all the plane people witness the footage for the first time. I can’t help but imagine my own experience on that day and seeing and hearing about what happened for the first time myself.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I’m about to chat with Justin Tinker who plays your Kevin’s other half. Describe sharing the stage with Justin in three words…
JASON SCOTT: Safe, Emotional, FUN
RAPID FIRE WITH COME FROM AWAY’s KEVIN J., JUSTIN TINKER
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You’re portraying both Kevin J. and Ali, two characters whose stories couldn’t be more different. What has been the biggest challenge of bringing both of them to life?
JUSTIN TINKER: This is a great question. Of the two characters, I feel more personally connected to Kevin J. I think we share a similar sense of humor and sass, but my biggest challenge has been finding his heart. At first glance, many of his lines can come across as snappy or arrogant. But I keep reminding myself that Kevin T wouldn’t have been with Kevin J for five years if that was all there was to him. That has led me to ask, “What made Kevin T fall in love with Kevin J?” Finding the answer to that question has helped me approach him with more empathy and complexity.
Ali has been a very different experience because, in many ways, he is nothing like me. My goal has been to honor his culture while still bringing my own truth to the role. Since I’m not Egyptian, I was initially most concerned about getting the accent right. But beyond that, I realized I could connect to Ali through my own experiences. As a Black man in America, I’ve experienced moments where I’ve felt judged or treated as an outsider, and that emotional truth has helped me better understand Ali’s journey.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Aside from the multiple roles, How has this show challenged you in new ways?
JUSTIN TINKER: Being born on September 12, 2001, I don’t have any personal memories of 9/11, so I couldn’t draw from my own experience. That made finding an emotional connection to the story a challenge at first. Instead, I leaned on the real stories of the people who lived through it (my parents and most of my cast mate)and connected to the show’s universal themes of compassion, resilience, and community. This production has also been a vocal beast for me. Once we started doing full runs, it became a mental challenge to stay present in each moment while also thinking five steps ahead because of all the moving parts. Throughout the process, though, I’ve continued to surprise myself. I’ve always felt most confident in my dancing and acting, but this show has challenged me to grow as a vocalist. It’s helped me realize that singing is a strength of mine as well. I’m especially grateful to our director, Susan Walsworth, and our music director, Trey Lundquist, for believing in me and giving me the confidence to grow. Thanks to their guidance, I’ve discovered a new level of confidence in my voice, and I’m incredibly thankful for the opportunity.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Come From Away is known for its demanding dialects and lightning-fast character changes. Which aspect has required the most preparation?
JUSTIN TINKER: Oh it’s definitely the lighting fast character changes. I’m constantly checking the script to make sure I know where I am and who I’m playing at every moment. For the first time, I even created a track sheet (a spreadsheet that maps out every character I play, along with my costume changes and scene transitions). Because I switch between multiple characters, sometimes only a few lines apart, staying organized has become essential to keeping up with the pace of the show.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Has there been a rehearsal moment that reminded you why this musical has resonated with audiences around the world?
JUSTIN TINKER: One moment that really stands out to me was our first full read-through after learning all of the music. I remember Trey telling us that even though the show wasn’t on its feet yet and our faces would probably be buried in our scripts, we should still be able to hear the emotion in the storytelling. As we performed the entire show for the first time, it felt like a light bulb went off. I remember thinking, “Oh yeah, we have the right people to tell this story.” Even without the staging, costumes, or choreography, the heart of the show was already there, and that was a really special moment to witness.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Finish this sentence: Audiences will leave Come From Away feeling __________.
JUSTIN TINKER: how important community is.
RAPID FIRE WITH COME FROM AWAY DIRECTOR SUSAN WALSWORTH
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Come From Away has become one of the most beloved musicals of the last decade. How did you come to be directing it for The Keeton?
SUSAN WALSWORTH: It is an amazing story and Donna knew that my son Sevon was in it last summer and that I was very familiar with the show so when she asked me, I jumped at the chance.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You’ve both directed and performed on The Keeton stage over the years. How has your experience as an actor shaped the way you approach directing?
SUSAN WALSWORTH: I believe that being an actor before becoming a director gives me a better perspective of things that work, and also things that don’t; That includes using the uniqueness of the Keeton stage, my rehearsal process, and communication with my cast.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: The creators of Come From Away often say the show isn’t a 9/11 musical, but rather a 9/12 musical Do you agree with that assessment? If so, why (or why not)?
SUSAN WALSWORTH: I both agree and disagree, yes it is about the stories of the people of Gander and the plane people the days following 9/11 but we wouldn’t have these stories to tell if the horrible attacks hadn’t happened that day.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Come From Away relies on a seamless blend of storytelling and music. What’s it been like collaborating with music director Trey Lundquist to bring this incredible score to life?
SUSAN WALSWORTH: I met Trey during our first production meeting for the show and quickly realized that we both had the same vision for bringing this show to the stage. The vocals in the show are dynamic and have to tell the story and Trey has done an amazing job making this stellar cast sound absolutely incredible! Trey and I have developed a great working relationship and will remain friends once this process is complete. I hope I get to work with him again in the future.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What do you hope audiences are still thinking about on the drive home after experiencing this production?
SUSAN WALSWORTH: I hope audiences walk away with the kindness in their hearts and feeling uplifted that there is hope for a brighter future even during a time of darkness.
———-
Alongside Melissa Silengo, Jason Scott and Justin Tinker, the cast of The Keeton‘s Come From Away is made of a who’s who of area talent including Brian Best, Leslie King, Stephanie Jackson, Jack Joiner, Ben Gregory, Ashlie Welte-Lopez, Clair Yancey, Jayden Murphy, Yolanda Treece and Tyler Samuel. The Show’s production team, helmed by director Susan Walsworth, includes music director Trey Lundquist, choreographer McKenna Driver and stage manager Kaleigh Ruiz.
The Keeton being the area’s only dinner theatre, there’s always a dinner option accompanying the show. For Come From Away, the pre-show in-flight meal will feature a dinner salad, pulled pork barbecue sandwich (a pre-0rdered substitute of grilled salmon is available for a slight up-charge), red skin potato salad, a side of mixed veggies and lemon bar for dessert.
The Keeton‘s Come From Away marks the opening of the company’s 2026/2027 season with performances Friday, August 17 thru Sunday, August 30. CLICK HERE for tickets. For Friday and Saturday performances, doors are at 5:45pm with dinner service until 6:45 and show beginning at 7pm. Thursdays are show only with doors at 6:30pm and show at 7pm. For Sunday matinees, doors open at 12:45pm with meal service until 1:45pm and showtime at 2pm.
The Keeton‘s Come From Away is ultimately a story about what can happen when strangers choose to care for one another in the face of unimaginable circumstances. With a director and cast who have clearly connected deeply with that message, The Keeton’s production promises to offer Nashville audiences not only an unforgettable musical experience, but also a timely reminder of the power of community. That sounds like a pretty perfect reason to let Come From Away take you on its journey.
Next up following Come From Away, The Keeton presents John Patrick‘s wickedly funny mid-century comedy The Curious Savage on stage October 9-25. So you don’t miss out on upcoming shows at The Keeton Dinner Theatre, follow them on Facebook, X and Instagram.
Interested in coverage for your latest entertaining endeavor? Click the contact page and drop me a note. You can also follow JHP Entertainment on Instagram and Facebook. In the meantime, #GoSeeTheShow!