Frequently described as Sherlock Holmes meets Monty Python, The Play That Goes Wrong began as a spirited production created by the UK-based Mischief Theatre Company. What started as a fringe production quickly snowballed into a West End hit and Broadway favorite, delighting audiences with its perfectly timed mishaps, collapsing sets, and characters determined to press on no matter how disastrous things become.
Now, that same brand of orchestrated mayhem takes center stage at The Keeton Theatre from April 10–26, bringing Nashville audiences a whirlwind of laughter where every missed cue, falling prop, and “accidental” blunder must be carefully executed in order to keep the illusion of screw-up believable.
As the cast and crew prepared for their opening night, we caught up with cast members Josh Mertz (Chris), Leslie King (Sandra), Hazen Lawson (Dennis), and director Erin-Grace Bailey to talk about the art of controlled chaos, the technical precision behind the comedy, and exactly what it takes to make everything go so hilariously wrong.
—–
RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH THE KEETON’s THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG
RAPID FIRE WITH THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG’s JOSH MERTZ
JHPENTERTAINMENT:As a Nashville native and frequent Keeton performer, what makes coming back for this show feel special?
JOSH MERTZ: The Keeton is my theatre home. I absolutely love performing here! Kevin and Donna Driver are amazing, and they run this space with such care- which is one of the many reasons I keep coming back. The reason I auditioned for this particular show in the first place is the absolute dream production team of Erin-Grace Bailey, Allison Gaddy, and Fiona Barrett. I love getting to work with them so much! I think they bring fun energy and passion for this craft into the rehearsal space. I appreciate the production team’s ability to create nuanced performances and challenge us to be the best actors we can be. Allison is an unsung hero as our stage manager because without her calm presence backstage running the show, there simply wouldn’t be one. Fun fact – during the audition, I told the team I would play “Tree number 1” just to work with them again, and the trust they had in me to play Chris is just an added bonus, as it is a dream role for me to portray.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Chris takes himself very seriously—how fun is it to play someone completely unaware of how wrong things are going?
JOSH MERTZ: Chris has been such a fun character to build. In my interpretation of Chris, he is your typical over the top, overbearing director with a “the show must go on” mentality. I do believe he’s more oblivious to how wrong things are going earlier on in the show but … Chris certainly has a breaking point! This show is fun as an actor because while we know all the things that will “go wrong,” our characters do not always see what’s coming. And hopefully, neither does the audience!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You’ve done everything from Ragtime to Footloose—how does comedy like this challenge you differently?
JOSH MERTZ: I consider myself as primarily a character actor, so this show was right in my wheelhouse. I think what challenges me the most as a performer is how fast-paced and high energy the show is. This has been the most challenging show I’ve ever done in my life. Between the running, jumping and falling, by the end 0f the night Chris is so exhausted. The play goes by so fast, and I hope the audience is ready to buckle up for this rollercoaster of a show.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What’s the most difficult accidental moment you have to execute on purpose each night?
JOSH MERTZ: The most difficult moment for me personally is having to fall off of a high platform. Erin-Grace prioritizes actor safety in all of the choreographed chaos of this show, so it has been incredible to know that I would never be asked to do anything that was going to put me at risk of injury. I won’t give away the stage magic, but it was definitely something I had to mentally ease my way into.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What’s your personal favorite moment of chaos in the show?
JOSH MERTZ: My favorite moment of utter chaos is the ending of Act 2. The entire cast is on stage, and it is so fun to all be there together for the culmination of the show. I cannot give too much away, so you will just have to get your tickets to see how it ALL falls apart.
RAPID FIRE WITH THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG’s LESLIE KING
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Sandra has to juggle performance and disaster at the same time—what’s the trick to balancing both?
LESLIE KING: I’ve found that being able to trust my fellow cast mates is super important. All of our disasters are carefully constructed and executed and if I’m focusing on what everyone else is doing it doesn’t leave much bandwidth to focus on myself and my character. Because I trust my cast mates to be where they’re supposed to be and do what they need to do, it makes it easy to balance both.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Sandra’s claim to fame is that her aunt is Dame Diana Rigg. In your real life, who’s your favorite name drop?
LESLIE KING: I have a connection to Gabe Gibbs (played Elder Price in The Book of Mormon on Broadway 2015-2017) and his family. He probably wouldn’t have any idea who I am but his parents would. We went to church with them for about a decade, and I went to high school with his brother.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You’ve previously appeared in area productions as varied as Cabaret and Puffs. Where does a physical comedy like The Play That Goes Wrong fall in the mix?
LESLIE KING: It has been so much fun to work on. While I’ve done comedies before, the physicality of this show is unlike anything I’ve done before. It adds an extra element of challenge, but I’ve absolutely loved it.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What’s the hardest moment to keep a straight face when everything is going wrong? AND Who among your fellow cast mates breaks easiest?
LESLIE KING: I’d have to say watching David Fonville inch his way off stage after the gurney fails is high on the list of moments I struggle to keep a straight face. Either that, or the ring around the rosey scene at the end of act one where they get stuck going in circles on the same scene. Luckily I’m offstage for that so I can laugh as much as I like.
Honestly we’ve all worked pretty hard to stay composed but occasionally I’ll still get Josh Mertz to break.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: The Keeton’s resident scenic designer Kevin Driver has his work cut out for him with this show. What’s your favorite set element that Goes Wrong?
LESLIE KING: I think the walls or the platform are both great elements. They’re both completely unexpected if you haven’t seen the show before and I love the moment we really catch people off guard with elements like those.
RAPID FIRE WITH THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG’s HAZEN LAWSON
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Even though he is a bit of a novice on the stage, Dennis quickly realizes even his flubs get a memorable reaction from the audience. How much fun are you having leaning into that aspect of the character?
HAZEN LAWSON: It’s been a lot of fun digging into how Dennis sees himself on and off the stage. His biggest dream is to be in “the big leagues” with actors like Robert, Chris, and Sandra, and I think he just can’t even believe he gets to be on stage with these talented actors. Dennis strives so hard to do everything right, but every time he messes up – to fanfare from the audience – it’s another reminder that he’s not as polished as his fellow actors. Playing off the juxtaposition of Max has also been a lot of fun; where Max pushes for attention from the audience, Dennis is absolutely mortified by it.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: This show is very physical—what’s the most demanding part for you?
HAZEN LAWSON: The ending scene of Act I is a bit of a gauntlet for me when Dennis can’t quite seem to get his lines right. It’s a full-on mental circus act keeping track of the script and blocking while everything loops over and over again to make sure that everything runs exactly as it should every time. And then by the end of the scene, I’ve been thrown on the floor, drenched with several glasses of scotch, and Dennis is having a full-blown panic attack. It’s a big push, but it’s absolutely worth it for the utter catharsis those ending lines bring.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Your show bio reveals a love of reading, knitting, and hiking—all seemingly tranquil—How do you mentally shift into the fast-paced chaos of The Play That Goes Wrong?
HAZEN LAWSON: Funnily enough, I think my love for my grandma activities as I call them has been crucial to helping me keep up with the show. Every single joke, line, and practical effect has been knit into this intricate story that will start to unravel the second a thread gets dropped. Tranquility, and especially attention to detail, is the name of the game when you need to keep a level head and stay in complete control while the show seemingly falls apart around you. To the audience it should look like total chaos, but for those of us up on stage it should be running like clockwork.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What’s one moment where timing is absolutely everything for the joke to land?
HAZEN LAWSON: Is saying the entire show an option?? If I had to choose just one moment, it would probably be at the beginning of Act II where Dennis’ lines are cut off by Trevor having fun with some sound cues. It’s a moment where I really have to be in sync with Wanderson Rezende – who’s playing Trevor up in the fake sound booth – and with Steve Love – our actual sound designer/operator in the real sound booth – to make sure everything lines up.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Have you had any almost mishaps that felt a little too real?
HAZEN LAWSON: During one of our rehearsals, the set may have fallen apart just a little too early. Thankfully everyone was where they needed to be and no one was in any danger – but I will say I have a newfound perspective on Dennis’ reaction to almost being crushed by a flat.
RAPID FIRE WITH THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG’s DIRECTOR, ERIN-GRACE BAILEY
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You’ve directed a wide range of work, from the Bell Witch Fall Festival‘s Smoke and Women In Theatre‘s Tiny Beautiful Things to The Keeton‘s 2024 production of William Inge‘s Bus Stop—what drew you to The Play That Goes Wrong?
ERIN-GRACE BAILEY: This was kind of a dream show for me. I’m a big fan of a lot of British work and grew up on a lot of that classic slapstick comedy. I was that weird teenager that would rather re-watchI Love Lucy and Downton Abbey than keep up with the latest fad. That interest grew in high school when I discovered Oscar Wilde and then even more in college when I started studying Noel Coward. I got to see the National Tour of The Play That Goes Wrong my sophomore year for free after a friend gave up some tickets. I had no idea what I was walking into but immediately fell in love with it. I felt like it combined all of my favorite things. I’ve been an avid follower of Mischief Theatre Company who created the play ever since. The work they’re doing is not only incredibly creative and entertaining but extremely impressive. It’s an honor to bring a little piece of that to middle Tennessee.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You had me at I Love Lucy, but I digress…How do you begin to direct something that’s supposed to look completely chaotic?
ERIN-GRACE BAILEY: Well, Step One is to swallow your anxiety and pray, haha. Step Two is a lot of research. We spent a lot of time on YouTube looking at other production, reading and then re-reading the script, and talking to people we knew who had done the show before.
A lot goes into this show. Our technical director Kevin Driver has outdone himself. The set for this show is no easy feat, and we’ve had it for a while for the actors to practice on. Everyone in this show has spent a lot of time learning stage combat and stunts, memorizing their lines early on, and fine tuning little things so they’re shocking to the audience but predictable for the people they’re on stage with.
Above all, I want to recognize that while every show takes a village, this one especially does. Everyone apart of this has put in a lot of work, contributed ideas, and collaborated to bring out the best in one another. Nothing about this show is possible without an amazing team.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What’s the biggest challenge in balancing technical precision with comedic freedom?
ERIN-GRACE BAILEY: Time. We could have probably rehearsed this show for the rest of the year and continued to have made discoveries, but in a rehearsal period, there has to be sort of a cut off for new things. I still encourage the actors to play so it’s fresh every night, but there are some pieces of the show that have to happen the exact same way every time so all of the elements can work together. It’s a fine line, but this cast and crew has mastered it with professionalism.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: You touched on it a bit earlier, but let’s delve into it a tad more…What has this show’s technical team done particularly well in bringing your vision of “controlled chaos” to life?
ERIN-GRACE BAILEY: Their dedication and communication has been nothing short of phenomenal. There’s a lot of bouncing ideas off one another. I think Kevin and I have had a phone call almost daily for the past two weeks talking about magnets and measurements. Ironically, for something to look so chaotic, it all has to be extremely precise. We’ve used the script as a formula, and then I think just about every designer has added little things of their own, too. It’s also a lot of fun to be directing a show where the designers get to bring out their comedic side as well. They’re so creative and lovely. I can’t thank them enough for the hours they’ve put in on this show.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What do you hope audiences leave with after seeing The Keeton‘s production of The Play That Goes Wrong?
ERIN-GRACE BAILEY: As Dolly Parton says, “If you see someone without a smile, give them yours!” We’re living in some dark times. Even the day-to-day struggles just feel a little bit extra heavy lately. I hope folks get to come in to the theatre, have a nice meal, and just leave those struggles at the door for a little while. I hope they’re entertained, that they laugh, and they get to have an evening of no internet – just a bunch of strangers in a crowded room enjoying some weird, hilarious, impressive art.
—–
The Play That Goes Wrong runs April 10–26 at The Keeton Theatre, located at 108 Donelson Pike, Nashville, TN 37214. Friday & Saturday Doors at 5:45pm/Dinner at 6pm and Show at 7pm. Sunday matinee Doors at 12:45pm/Meal at 1pm and Show at 2pm. Please note that the two Thursday evening performances during the run are show-only with Doors at 6:30pm and Show at 7pm. Show Only Tickets: $32.00 (Thursday performances), Adult Dinner and Show: $42.00, Child Dinner and Show: $37.00. For a slight upcharge, Salmon can be chosen as the dinner entree. Group tickets receive a discount. Please call the Box Office at 615.883.8375 or CLICK HERE for tickets.
During the run of The Play That Goes Wrong, The Keeton will present The Keeton Community Wind Ensemble’s Spring Concert An Evening at the Theatre, directed by Dillon Wright and featuring a selection of music from the movies. Door open for this one-night-only event at 6:30pm with the performances beginning at 7pm on Tuesday, April 14. Tickets are $15. CLICK HERE to purchase. Following The Play That Goes Wrong, on Tuesday, May 2 at 7pm, it’s time for The Keeton’s Annual Gala directed by The Keeton‘s own Donna Driver with musical direction by Jane Kelley. This year’s annual fundraiser for the theatre is themed: Role Reversal. Tickets to the gala are $60. Gala tickets include dinner, a chance to win some great prizes donated by supporters of the theatre and the opportunity to be among the first to purchase Season Tickets for The Keeton’s upcoming 2026-2027 Season. CLICK HERE to purchase gala tickets. So you don’t miss out on upcoming shows at The Keeton Dinner Theatre, follow them on Facebook, X and Instagram.
Interested in coverage for your latest entertaining endeavor? Click the contact page and drop me a note. You can also follow JHP Entertainment on Instagram and Facebook. In the meantime, #GoSeeTheShow!