Pop quiz: What happens when Broadway favorites, high school nostalgia, and one seriously chic Nashville venue collide for one night only? Enter That’s So High School, the latest installment in the ever-buzzy Off Broadway series at Analog at The Hutton Hotel on Saturday, April 18. Led by the unstoppable Rachel Potter (The Addams Family, Evita) and featuring a lineup that includes Elle McLemore (Heathers, Bring It On, Grease Live), Marty Thomas (Xanadu, Wicked), and Jelani Remy (High School Musical, The Lion King, Ain’t Too Proud: The Life and Times of The Temptations), this one-night-only event is serving throwback realness with powerhouse vocals to match. Before the curtain goes up (and the prom afterparty kicks in), we put the cast through our signature Rapid Fire 20Q because, after all, as the song says, “We’re All in This Together!”
—————
RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH BROADWAY PERFORMERS HEADED TO ANALOG FOR OFF BROADWAY: THAT’s SO HIGH SCHOOL
RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH OFF BROADWAY: THAT’s SO HIGH SCHOOL‘s ELLE MCLEMORE
JHPENTERTAINMENT: With the built-in pedigree of having originated the Broadway roles of both Bring It On’s Eva and Heathers: The Musical’s Heather McNamara, plus playing Patty Simcox in 2016’s Grease Live, you seem tailor-made for Off Broadway: That’s So High School. Did it take much convincing for you to agree to be part of it?
ELLE McLEMORE: Thank you, Jonathan! HahaI I will say, I normally am the first person to typecast myself out of things, but this couldn’t be more on brand, so zero convincing at all. To quote Heathers–“High school never really ends.”
When I found out Taylor Louderman was on board as well, I was very excited to reunite with her, as we made our Broadway debuts together playing the villain and hero in Bring It On The Musical! In a way, It feels like we went to high school and grew up together, so it’s gonna be really fun being onstage again all grown up.
I’ve also never been to Nashville before, so I am very excited to spend a bit of time here with this really special group of people!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: With each Off Broadway at Analog at Hutton Hotel, Rachel Potter has proven herself something along the lines of Music City’s own Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon of the theatre world, so…How did you and Rachel first met?
ELLE McLEMORE: That is AMAZING! Rachel is such a powerhouse. Not only do I think she’s one of the greatest vocalists of our time, she’s also an entrepreneur, mom, actress, and the director/ producer responsible for bringing all this theatre magic to Music City! It’s truly special what she has created and I don’t know how she sleeps? LOL!
I first was introduced to Rachel ironically (or by fate’s design) while I was doing Bring It On in NYC. She was doing a concert called The Glitter Ball at New World Stages. I remember being on Pinterest for WEEKS leading up to this event, as we were all trying to figure out what “sparkly” outfits to wear, and how to rhinestone our eye makeup. I have photos for receipts if you need. Needless to say, I’ve since been a fan, and honored to be a part of her Kevin Bacon lore.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Taking a queue from your Insta, Who would you include on your Mount Rushmore of High School characters? and YES it’s OK to include at least one that you have played yourself…
ELLE McLEMORE: I LOVE IT. Okay I need you to know how hard I thought about this, as these games are my world. So here we go:
1. Patty Simcox (Grease)
I know this is controversial, and the correct choice should probably be Danny Zuko or Sandy, but since you said I could pick one of my characters, this is the one I would go with. Rydell High School simply would not function without Patty Simcox. She was head of the cheerleading squad, student council, yearbook committee, holding dance competitions, all while literally running for office (Student Council Vice President). She embodies high school, through every generation. All I can say is…missed opportunity, Danny.
2. Troy Bolton (High School Musical)
I had a cardboard cutout of Zac Efron from Blockbuster in my childhood bedroom that lives rent free in my heart forever. So maybe that’s subconsciously why I think he’s “peak” as the kids say, but I actually think it’s more! He challenged high school hierarchies and gender norms with his passion for both basketball and theatre that I honestly just find so inspiring. He’s got that perfect “coming of age “ and “breaking the status quo” arc it requires to be on my mountain range.
3. Regina George (Mean Girls)
Although Heathers came 15 or so years earlier, Mean Girls was my generation’s EVERYTHING. If you’re a millennial you probably lived and breathed this movie while wearing your Juicy Couture sweatsuit and Tiffany and Co necklace. If Troy Bolton is the “good guy” archetype, Regina George represents that beautiful “dictator” role that exists in almost every high school setting. Also, I just adore Rachel McAdams and obviously Taylor Louderman, too.
4. Cher Horowitz (Clueless)
This was hard. I could have gone Marty McFly, Tracy Turnblad or even Veronica Sawyer for honorable mentions, but we have to round it out with Cher. There’s something about her being the optimistic (clueless) protagonist that annoyingly gets away with everything that is just “so high school” to me. I also just love her outfits and the 90’s Beverly Hills setting. As IF!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: In preparation of chatting with you I did an online sleuthing via your fabulous socials, where I learned that last year you traveled to Japan to be part of a Masterclass. What was that experience like?
ELLE McLEMORE: I am honored to have been a small part of your “doom scroll”, Jonathan. Thank you so much. If you haven’t been to Japan, please put it on your bucket list, ASAP! It’s truly life changing. It was very special for me, as I am a quarter Japanese, and I got to see a lot of where I came from. My mom is also a performer (she is a dancer turned Las Vegas showgirl) and Tokyo and Okinawa Japan is where she began her performer journey at 18. So to be at the birth place of where it began for the both of us, then teaching students younger than me was one of those cull circle moments. To have students show up in a classroom half way across the world singing your songs in Japanese, was just something I never imagined possible. Even with a small language barrier, It showed me that the language of musical theatre is truly universal. They are so incredibly respectful, disciplined and passionate. Something I really took note of is, for a culture that has a reputation of being reserved, they are also so deeply open, raw and brave. Their talent was INSANE. I left there thinking, wow I really need to step my game up…
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What’s next for you?
ELLE McLEMORE: I’m really excited about this next chapter. I’ve been focusing a lot the last three years on building my own production studio, Established Magic with my husband, Josh. We have created some beautiful cinematic work in partnership with some of the biggest brands all over the world, that I’m really proud of. I started acting professionally in LA when I was 16, and as the entertainment landscape has evolved, it became really clear to me I needed to create my stories, on my own terms. It’s hard as an artist to give your power away to an entity outside of yourself, and I really admire people that go out there and do their own thing— exactly like what you’re doing here, Jonathan!
I also host a show/podcast called PLAYDATE, where we play games (like the Mount Rushmore one!)— it’s adult slumber party game night vibes on the internet. It kind of blew up on YouTube, so I have been slowly integrating it into longer form content with interviews. Aside from that, I would just love to to keep blending storytelling/performing/traveling and creating an expansive career— along with spend as much time with my fur son, my golden retriever Marshmallow, as possible (main priority). And I’m always open to jumping back on stage when the right project comes along. But ONLY if it’s set in high school.
RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH OFF BROADWAY: THAT’s SO HIGH SCHOOL‘s MARTY THOMAS
JHPENTERTAINMENT: In 2019 you released the album Slow Dancing with a Boy. At the time, it was described as a prom-themed piece, so you seem a natural choice for Off Broadway: That’s So High School. Was it an immediate yes when Rachel asked you to be part of this fun night of musical memories?
MARTY THOMAS: Absolutely! I threw a prom for my album release party/concert, and Rachel was both on the album and at the prom! We had such a great time, I can’t imagine that evening wasn’t partially responsible for a prom coming to Nashville! We had such a blast. I’m so glad we get to do it again!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: On your album Slow Dancing with a Boy, Rachel provided guest vocals on the track “Dreamlover”. How did that come about? AND…any chance you two might perform it live at That’s So High School?
MARTY THOMAS: I love that record so much. I don’t think we will be performing that, mainly because it’s a Broadway themed evening. When Rachel lived in NYC, we had a country band with our best friend Jamey Ray. We would rearrange pop tunes to have bluegrass and country vibes. This Mariah Carey tune was my favorite of our collection. I just HAD to get a studio recording of it.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Your Broadway credits include Wicked and Xanadu. I’m just gonna admit it…I LOVE all things Xanadu. Whether we are talking about ONJ’s movie or the musical. What’s your favorite memory of your time with Xanadu on Broadway?
MARTY THOMAS: Oh gosh finding just one is impossible. Xanadu was such a huge window of my life, but the tremendous cast is the highlight for me. I got to work with some of the most talented iconic performers out there and I’ll never forget it. The Tony awards was a definitive highlight as well!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Any Spoilers for what the Nashville audience can expect from you at That’s So High School?
MARTY THOMAS: Those lucky folks are in for a fun nostalgic evening. Amazing singers, great band, super cool ambiance, great drinks, I’m hoping everyone gets dressed up for the prom theme!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: As much as I wanna ask about your 1992 Star Search Junior win over some girl named Britney Spears, I’ll just ask WHEN can we expect OR…What have you got coming up next?
MARTY THOMAS: Oh man, Slow Dancing With A Boy really would make an amazing musical. I’ll have to get back to you on that! I’m touring so much this year, but have been working on a new album slowly but surely!
RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH OFF BROADWAY: THAT’s SO HIGH SCHOOL‘s JELANI REMY
JHPENTERTAINMENT: In 2019, you and Rachel Potter were among those performing at a gala celebrating Broadway composer & lyricist, Andrew Lippa. Was that the first time you and Rachel met? AND How did she convince you to be part of her latest Off Broadway series of one-night-only concert events here in Nashville?
JELANI REMY: Rachel and I met while I was on tour doing High School Musical maybe 2006 ish? Our cast crossed paths with the casts from the park and I was introduced to her incredible talents and connected to her beautiful heart. We have always kept in touch rooting for each other ever since so when she called me to be part of this – I immediately said yes! Well, to be honest -she asked me earlier but I was booked at Disneyworld which is actually ironic. However, I think being part of this show particularly is quite perfection!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: To my way of thinking, Grease is the granddaddy of all high school musicals, therefore, High School Musical is the daddy, or at the the older brother. It has been 20 years since the phenom began, after all. Having played Chad Danforth in High School Musical during the 2007-2008 concert tour, what is it about these types of musicals that resonates as time passes?
JELANI REMY: We have to talk about the fact that the first solo I sang was “Those Magic Changes” my freshman year of high school! It changed me. Bit by that theater bug forever. Fast forward to landing High School Musical. The beginning of my career!
The thing about these shows is that those years- the high school ones are so formidable and relatable to everyone! The friends you had- the phases – the teachers. They made you. They stay with you and if you happened to be in the theater department.. it was the start of something new……. lol
JHPENTERTAINMENT: While I saw you on stage in the original High School Musical national tour, it wasn’t until a few years later when I not only saw you as Simba in The Lion King, but was also fortunate enough to get to know you a little during the tours four week residency at Nashville‘s TPAC. What’s among your favorite memories of your time with The Lion King? AND…Any chance Nashville audiences might get a little Simba song during Off Broadway: That’s So High School?
JELANI REMY: My favorite memory of The Lion King is 10 years of telling an iconic story to so many! I really grew up with that show and Simba means more to man than anyone will know! Though I did the show for a bit- no show was the same! That’s magic of theater. I will say I had an absolute blast in Nashville on tour and can’t wait to be back!
I can’t give any secrets away! Come to the show and find out!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: While Off Broadway: That’s So High School brings you back to your roots—HSM having been your first pro gig (if my research proves correct)—it’s not your first time to revisit Wildcats country. In 2024, you directed a HSM tour cast reunion at New York’s iconic 54 Below. What was a highlight of that night for you, both as a HSM alum and as the show’s director?
JELANI REMY: As I put on my director choreographer hat. I was honored to be given this opportunity to bring my Wildcat family together to revisit the show and lift up our musical director Bryan Louiselle. A highlight of that night was our version of “When There Was Me and You” It was beautiful and for Our Bryan.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: All right, I can’t do this interview with you and not mention something. A few years ago, at my request, you created a video encouraging the cast of a local production of The Lion King Jr. As someone who got their professional start not long after their own high school experience how important is it to encourage the next generation of performers?
JELANI REMY: Yes, yes and more yes! They are the future! It’s vital! It’s a joy of mine to let others know that they can and should! We are essential to humanity.
RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH OFF BROADWAY: THAT’s SO HIGH SCHOOL‘s RACHEL POTTER
JHPENTERTAINMENT: How did you come up with the idea for the Off Broadway series at Analog?
RACHEL POTTER: This series was really a happy accident! I have always wanted to start an event series here in Nashville for Broadway/musical theater folk, but the venue had never really made itself known. I actually reached out to Analog to be the location for my Broadway album release party in Nashville, but they said, “Actually, we have this idea for a Wicked themed event, maybe you could collaborate with us on it and maybe host it?” So, together, we came up with this fabulous event, and it was such a success that the Hutton and Analog were excited to keep it going – and so am I! I’ve fallen into the role of producer, performer and host, which is a big job, but the payoff is so worth it. My good friend Chris Brent Davis is the musical brain behind my visions, and I couldn’t do it without him!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: The latest, Off Broadway: That’s So High School is the fourth in the ongoing series, right? Can you give me a sneak peek as far as what shows are being represented this go-round?
RACHEL POTTER: Yes, the 4th! So far, we have had Witch, Please! (Wicked), Best of Broadway, and An Evening of Magic (Disney). This month’s show will visit all the most popular musicals about high school: Dear Evan Hansen, Mean Girls, Bring it On, and Grease, of course! Also, a very important detail, we are having a Prom Dance Afterparty in the space right after the concert!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: So…Is it too late to request “Reproduction” or “Cool Rider” from Grease 2?
RACHEL POTTER: Unfortunately, yes, but you’ll be happy to hear Grease is definitely represented from the first film!! You’ll have to put your requests in sooner next time… this takes lots of planning and having people learn numbers in advance!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: For this Rapid Fire 20Q, in addition to our conversation, I’m also chatting with Elle, Jelani & Marty. Who else have you lined up for Off Broadway: That’s So High School?
RACHEL POTTER: Oh, it is such a great lineup… in addition to those legends Taylor Louderman (Tony Nominee for Regina George in Mean Girls, Lauren in Kinky Boots, Bring it On), Carolina Rial (The Voice), Ben Laxton (Book of Mormon Broadway), Jada Wasserman (TikTok Star), and Nashville Musical theater artists Erin McCracken and Dustin Davis.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What do you have audiences take with them after attending one of your Off Broadway nights? AND…what’s up next for this concert series?
RACHEL POTTER: JOY and CONNECTION. So much of what’s going on in the world today is dark and always seems to be getting worse. At the end of the day, if I can bring meaningful connection and joy to my community through music and storytelling, then that is a huge win. We are all walking this human experience together, and while different, we’re actually way more similar than we are led to believe. Our night allows music and theater to tell human stories and brings our Nashville community together in a way they aren’t accustomed to. It’s thrilling to be a part of, and to hear from the audience how much they are getting from our evenings together.
What’s coming next? Just you wait! If Nashville continues to show up, we will only keep growing this special thing and getting cooler opportunities to create theater magic with Analog! July 11 will be The Room Where it Happened, featuring music of protest and patriotism, from musicals like Hamilton, Spring Awakening, Les Mis, Hair, and more! Then, our season closer on October 30 and 31 will be The Addams Family Musical in Concert! I will be reprising my role as Wednesday alongside Broadway, National Tour, and regional cast alumni, complete with the musical composer, Andrew Lippa, here to narrate! The hotel will incorporate a haunted house immersive element – it is going to be SO FUN. We are already dreaming up next year’s themes, and I’m so excited to begin casting them. Keep an eye on Off Broadway at the Hutton, Nashville – these one-night-only events are not to be missed!
—————
Just because these interviews are over, don’t think for a minute that class is dismissed! From Wildcats to Plastics, pep rallies to power ballads, Off Broadway: That’s So High School, Saturday, April 18 at 8pm (doors at 7) at Analog at The Hutton (1808 West End Ave. Nashville, 37203) promises a nostalgia-fueled night that hits every note—and then invites you to dance it out after. With a cast this stacked and a concept this irresistible, Off Broadway at Analog continues to prove that Music City has a serious theater heartbeat. Off Broadway : That’s So High School Reserved Seating Tickets are $60 and General Admission Tickets forare $35. You don’t need a permission slip, so consider this your official homework: CLICK HERE to grab your tickets, dress for the prom (obvi), and get ready to relive the glory days—now THAT’S an after school assignment I think we can all get into.
To keep up with all happenings at Analog at The Hutton, CLICK HERE or follow them on Facebook and Insta.
As always, if you wanna follow JHPEntertainment to find out who I’m chatting with for my next Rapid Fire Q&A, or for my take on the latest local and national theatre, music and movie offerings, visit JHPENTERTAINMENT.com or find us on Facebook, Insta and X.