From the first triumphant notes of the all-in opening number Be the Hero, The Keeton’s production of “Big Fish” announces itself with confidence, color, and heart. Andrew Lippa and John August’s Drama Desk–nominated musical has always walked a delicate line between spectacle and sincerity, and under the direction of Aaron Gray, this staging embraces both.
Gray keeps the father–son relationship firmly at the center. Even as witches appear, giants roam, and daffodils bloom by the hundreds, the emotional throughline never wavers: this is a story about legacy, about listening, and about what we choose to believe.
A
s Edward Bloom, Micheal Walley bursts onto the stage with charisma and conviction. From his first entrance, his speech pattern and delivery lands near Mark Twain’s distinctive Southern storytelling drawl — deliberate, charming, measured — and for some reason put me in mind of French Stewart’s Harry Solomon from “Third Rock from the Sun”, quick with an unexpected sarcastic bite. The blend gives Edward both homespun authenticity and razor-edged comedic timing, a balance that keeps the character from drifting into caricature. The subtle but effective vocal change between younger Edward to his more frail self in later years is quite interesting to take in.
Be the Hero sets the tone — brassy, buoyant, unapologetically theatrical — and Walley meets the marathon demands of Lippa’s eclectic score with stamina and emotional nuance. As Walley revealed in my recent Rapid Fire 20Q with the show’s director, Walley and two of his fellow cast members, he’s a self-proclaimed “actor who sings”. That said, his Edward isn’t simply performing for applause; he’s inviting us into possibility.
Edward’s early adventures unfold with theatrical flourish. Miya Nicole Burt delivers a bewitching — and yes, pun entirely intended — turn as The Witch. Her presence is equal parts playful and ominous, her vocals slicing cleanly through Lippa’s driving rhythms while maintaining an alluring mystique. In particular, during her early solo during The Witch, hers is a performance that anchors one of the show’s most pivotal revelations.
Then there is Karl. Portrayed by Gray Miller, the gentle giant is, quite literally, larger than life. Miller commands the stage both physically and emotionally, bringing warmth and childlike innocence to the towering role. Remarkably, he had never walked on stilts before rehearsals began — a fact that makes his comfort and control in performance all the more impressive. What could have been a novelty becomes a fully realized character, and one the audience revels in seeing.
Musically, the production is in confident hands. Under the direction of Ian Mannino, the orchestra navigates Lippa’s stylistic range — from Broadway brass to tender balladry to gospel-infused exuberance — with clarity and cohesion. Mannino ensures the score supports the storytelling rather than overpowering it.
Choreographer Andrea Campbell, working in clear collaboration with director Aaron Gray, makes masterful use of The Keeton’s intimate stage. With a cast of twenty, filling the space without overwhelming it is no small feat, yet the production never once feels crowded. Instead, it feels alive. From kick lines to tap and everything in between, the variety of choreography reflects the musical’s tonal shifts while showcasing the ensemble’s versatility. One can only imagine the rigor of rehearsals required to master such range within spatial constraints, and the ensemble rises to the challenge with precision and enthusiasm. Director Gray deserves equal praise for staging that maximizes every inch of the performance area, creating dynamic stage pictures that feel expansive, an appropriate nod to the story’s 2003 cinematic retelling courtesy Tim Burton‘s film adaptation, despite the venue’s modest footprint.
Equally essential to that visual storytelling is Kevin Driver‘s set design. From the opening scene in which the backdrop of the Bloom family house and picket fence appear in mostly in silhouette, there’s an immediate storybook feel to the actors’ surroundings. Balancing storybook whimsy with practical fluidity, the stage elements allow scenes to transition seamlessly from small-town Alabama to mythic landscapes without interrupting the show’s pacing or emotional rhythm. The stage area’s aquatic element…quite effective and fanciful.
If Walley’s Edward provides the fireworks, Claire Yancy as Edward’s lifelong love, Sandra provides the stillness — and the soaring vocals. Yancey’s vocal prowess is undeniable. Her tone is rich, controlled, and emotionally open, particularly in Time Stops, where the courtship unfolds in suspended romantic glow. As Sandra matures into the family’s emotional anchor, Yancey deepens the portrayal beautifully. Her performance of I Don’t Need a Roof becomes one of the evening’s most affecting moments — restrained, resolute, and vocally luminous.
Jacob Hinnen as Edward’s adult son, delivers a fully believable, emotionally grounded portrayal of Will Bloom. Hinnen never pushes for sympathy; instead, he allows Will’s frustration and skepticism to emerge organically. The result is authenticity. As Will prepares to become a father himself, the shift in perspective is subtle yet powerful. You believe him — every step of the way.
With an ensemble of twenty actors, it would be nearly impossible to single out every strong performance, but several deserve special mention. Audrey Bagley, as Josephine, perfectly portrays her devotion to Will while balancing a genuine fascination with her seemingly eccentric future father-in-law. Her warmth and quiet curiosity add texture to the generational dynamic at the heart of the story.
Ryman Stanton, portraying Young Will, delivers a heartfelt performance that marks his third production with the company, further securing his place as a full-fledged member of The Keeton family. His enthusiastic appreciation of his father’s tall tales strengthens and perfectly exemplifies the emotional bridge between past and present.
In the supporting but pivotal role of Jenny Hill, Jessica Fonville makes an impressive Keeton debut, convincingly aging nearly forty years over the course of the production. Her transformation, while only slightly visually different, is emotional and understated, grounding one of the show’s most poignant and surprising storylines to life.
There are also delightful scene-stealers throughout the ensemble. Among them, Wanderson Rezende, who has the rare ability to catch the audience’s eye with a subtle facial flex or an intentionally flamboyant gesture, commanding attention in both restraint and exuberance. Meanwhile, Tommy Anglim, another Keeton favorite, repeatedly makes audiences double-take with the quickness of his rapid costume changes, shifting characters — including Dr. Bennett — with ease and in record time.
As the story moves toward its conclusion, fantasy and reality stop competing and begin coexisting. The final sequences land with earned emotional resonance. YES, my eyes began to sweat! Walley softens into fragility without losing Edward’s spark. Hinnen allows Will’s understanding to shift naturally. Bagley’s support, a needed comfort. Yancey’s quiet strength anchors it all.
What makes The Keeton’s “Big Fish” succeed is not simply its theatrical flourish, inventive choreography, cohesive musical direction, or imaginative scenic design — though all are present in abundance. It is the belief at its center, and the message at its core: Heroes are not defined by perfection. They are defined by the stories that outlive them. In this heartfelt, thoughtfully crafted production, those stories will certainly swim long after the curtain falls.
BIG FISH continues at The Keeton through Sunday, February 22. Thursday performances are show only with Doors at 6:30pm and Show at 7pm. Friday & Saturday Doors at 5:45pm/Dinner at 6pm and Show at 7pm. Sunday matinee Doors at 12:45pm/Meal at 1pm and Show at 2pm. Show Only Tickets: $30.00 (Thursday performances), Adult Dinner and Show: $40.00, Child Dinner and Show: $35.00. CLICK HERE for tickets.
Following BIG FISH, The Keeton will present “The Play That Goes Wrong” with performances April 10-26. So you don’t miss out on upcoming shows at The Keeton Dinner Theatre, follow them on Facebook, X and Instagram.
Interested in coverage for your latest entertaining endeavor? Click the contact page and drop me a note. You can also follow JHP Entertainment on Instagram and Facebook. In the meantime, #GoSeeTheShow!