Directed by Lauren Shouse, 0pening Friday, October 21 and running through Sunday, October 30, Nashville Repertory Theatre presents the regional premiere of Bekah Brunstetter’s The Cake at TPAC’s Andrew Johnson Theatre (505 Deadrick Street). While perhaps best known for her writing and producing duties on the popular NBC drama, This Is Us, which garnered her and her fellow producers three consecutive Emmys from 2017-2019, Brunstetter’s also enjoyed success as a playwright. Her previous stage plays include: F*cking Art, Miss Lilly Gets Boned and Be a Good Little Widow. From the titles alone, you might surmise that the playwright pulls no punches. The Cake, which premiered in Los Angeles in 2015 and featured That 70s Show’s Debra Jo Rupp, with is simple sweet title and all, just might follow suit, considering the play was inspired, in part by her own father’s opposition to same-sex marriage and the headline-making Supreme Court case of Masterpiece Cakeshop vs Colorado Civil Rights Commission. The Cake centers ‘round Della, a kind, but conservative North Carolina baker who finds herself at an unexpected conscience crossroads when her goddaughter returns to her small town to ask Della to bake her wedding cake…for the wedding to her fiancée.
When I learned that one of my theatre crushes, Megan Murphy Chambers was heading the cast, I knew I had to chat with her and her co-stars for the latest installment of my recurring interview feature, Rapid Fire 20 Q.
RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH CAST OF NASHVILLE REPERTORY THEATRE’s THE CAKE
RAPID FIRE WITH MEGAN MURPHY CHAMBERS, DELLA IN THE REP’S THE CAKE
JHPEntertainment: Tell me everything we need to know about Della, the character you play in The Cake, The Rep’s latest production…
Megan Murphy Chambers: Della is a beautiful challenge. There are elements of her personality that are so easy for me to access – she’s friendly, enthusiastic, authentically interested in people, and loving. The acting starts when her deeply ingrained but rarely examined belief system stops her from showing an adored friend the respect and love they deserve when they need it most. There’s not an intentionally mean bone in Della’s body, but she’s short on backbone (mean or otherwise). I like to think about what might transpire in the 6 months after the play is over for her. I have high hopes for her, and her capability to open her heart and mind.
JHPEntertainment: While researching the show to prepare these questions for you and your fellow cast mates, I found the opening monologue script on line. During which, Della explains that you must follow the recipe exactly to ensure the perfect cake. This seems to pretty much lay out the thought process behind her character’s way of life and decision-making. A a general rule, are you yourself a recipe follower, a recipe adapter or a recipe creator? Feel free to answer this as it relates to the kitchen, or life as a whole.
Megan Murphy Chambers: Oh I am a recipe adaptor for sure. I’ll follow the directions enough to make sure whoever I’m feeding doesn’t end up with a plate of undercooked chicken, but in terms of the rest? All bets are off! I like cooking more than baking precisely because of the greater degree of freedom you have. And the greater degree of garlic. In life, I tend to be a rule-follower and people-pleaser, but that tendency lessens every single day. Which feels wonderful, to be honest.
JHPEntertainment: Now, I know you graduated from the University of Missouri, which, depending on who you ask, is either the midwest, or the south, and you’ve been in Nashville for some time now. Have you met any real life Dellas and might we see hints of them in your performance?
Megan Murphy Chambers: First of all, MIDWEST. I will not be taking questions at this time 🙂 I’ve lived all over the country, and have met Della-ish people everywhere. People with huge hearts that are coupled with years of a certain kind of shame and pressure. I carry pieces of some of them on stage every night, all of which help make her colorful. This one’s unfailing politeness, that one’s hypervigilance about “outsiders”, another one’s casual affection.
JHPEntertainment: From what I know, Della, though she is staunchly faithful to her convictions, isn’t made to appear the villain in this piece, but rather a sympathetic product of her environment. Is that a fair assessment? Why or why not?
Megan Murphy Chambers: Definitely a fair assessment. The brilliance of this writing means that throughout the play, we’re given reasons to root for every character, and reasons to feel disappointed in every character. Della maybe most of all. In my heart, I’m certain she’s making the wrong decision. But the generations of voices that echo in her head all day every day make it challenging to blame her in any simple way. We want to like her. We want her to do better.
JHPEntertainment: The show is titled The Cake, so I gotta know…do you have a sweet tooth? If so, what’s your favorite kind of cake? If not, what do you snack on instead?
Megan Murphy Chambers: I do indeed have a sweet tooth, but it’s not as powerful as my salt tooth. Cake is scrumptious, and it’s all I’ve thought about for the last month. I either want a spice cake with vanilla buttercream, or a classic Duncan Hines yellow cake from a box (don’t tell Della it’s not from scratch).
RAPID FIRE WITH CHRIS STRAND, TIM IN THE REP’S THE CAKE
JHPEntertainment: Alright, I tried not to gush while chatting with Megan, but just between us, how lucky are you to share the stage with one of my theatre crushes?
Christopher Strand: Very lucky! Megan is the heart and soul of this show and takes the audience on a hysterical and heartbreaking journey all at the same time- she can make you laugh out loud one minute and cry crocodile tears with her innate vulnerability the next- honored to share the stage with her!
JHPEntertainment: How would you describe Tim?
Christopher Strand: Tim is an amiable good ol boy who just happens to be a product of his upbringing and social environment- his beliefs have most likely been formed by his religious upbringing and casually soaking up Fox News and Incendiary right wing radio over the years- still he loves Della deeply and is a good hard working man who just happens to use food and humor as a substitute for the lack of Intimacy in his marriage.
JHPEntertainment: In researching to chat with you and your cast mates, it seems to me The Cake playwright, Bekah Brunstetter’s approach of using humor to spotlight a rather serious topic might have roots going back to classic sitcoms like All in the Family and The Jeffersons. Am I anywhere near close in that comparison? And why do you think that works?
Christopher Strand: Yes I think you’re close! Because even though Della and Tim are rather rigid in their beliefs , they are lovable characters , which persuades the audience to go on a sometimes difficult emotional journey with them- much like Archie Bunker , the audience is able to laugh at or with their imperfections and narrowminded-ness without necessarily agreeing with them!
JHPEntertainment: Are you a cake or pie guy in real life?
Christopher Strand: both unfortunately ! love most kinds although it may be somewhat unAmerican but I can’t do pumpkin pie sorry! banana cream, pecan pie, any kind of fruit pie- shoot I guess I am a pie guy!
JHPEntertainment: What’s one of your favorite lines in the show…yours or that of one of your fellow cast mates?
Christopher Strand: Jen says ” I don’t need you to make me a cake , I need you to LOVE me!” to me that sums up the show as much as one line could if possible
RAPID FIRE WITH MARIAH PARRIS, JEN IN THE REP’S THE CAKE
JHPEntertainment: What was it about the role of Jen that moved you to audition?
Mariah Parris: I had seen Lauren’s work before and knew working with her would be awesome, if given the chance. I was also excited to potentially work on a script with such a contemporary voice. I’ve never had the pleasure of working on a character so close to myself and feeling like I could bring so much of my own “isms” to the performance.
JHPEntertainment: As Jen, you share scenes, and an on-stage relationship with Maya Riley. You both appeared in The Rep’s Ragtime earlier this year. What is she like as a scene partner?
Mariah Parris: Maya and I used to do theatre together when we were little kids at Metro Parks with Carolyn German, and reconnected as adults when we both worked on Ragtime. We discovered that we still get on like a house on fire, so the biggest challenge with working with Maya has been to not interrupt rehearsal by laughing too much. She is an awesome scene partner and friend.
JHPEntertainment: While the show touts a cast of only four characters, there’s really a fifth, isn’t there? Care to give me an exclusive…who’s providing the voice of George, the reality show judge who’s only heard in voice-over?
Mariah Parris: Jonah Jackson is brilliant as the voice of George. He is a very accomplished and talented stage performer (last seen in The Rep’s Mary Poppins) and I’m so glad he’s getting a chance to show off his voice acting chops!
JHPEntertainment: As a kid, my birthday cakes were always a thing to behold as Mom would get the craftiest cake decorator around to recreate thematic delights featuring whatever my current obsession was, including, but not limited to: Star Wars, a Grease (the movie, not the frying additive) logo cake, a sheet-cake featuring the likeness of Miss Piggy and in my later years, as I began collecting Lucille Ball memorabilia, more than one cake decorated with classic images of I Love Lucy…Did you have theme-decorated cakes? If so, what was your favorite?
Mariah Parris: My lovely mom and dad went all out when I was a little girl- one year Barbie, one year Barney, and I’m sure there were many others though the memory escapes me now.
JHPEntertainment: Is there a moment in the show you think audiences will remember after leaving the theatre?
Mariah Parris: there are several beautifully emotional moments in the show that will resonate with different people, and it is my hope that each person leaves feeling like there was a moment that resonated with them specifically that they’ll never forget. Personally, I’ll never forget MMC hand feeding me carrot cake on stage—what a treat.
RAPID FIRE WITH MAYA RILEY, MACY IN THE REP’S THE CAKE
JHPEntertainment: This has been quite a year for you. You’ve just wrapped your fabulous starring role as AIDA, a performance everyone was raving about. Of course you started the year in Nashville Rep’s Ragtime and now you’re back at The Rep in The Cake. How excited are you for this momentum in your career as a performer and how are you keeping it going while keeping yourself grounded?
Maya Riley: Thank you so much! It’s been quite an unexpected journey, because I had planned to stay in New York City after graduating from NYU. I was just starting my career there when COVID hit, and after the theatre world basically stopped I moved back down here. I’ve really just started to get back into performing, and I’m so grateful that things are opening up again. Being back in Nashville feels right. I’m surrounded by family and friends that I love. It blows my mind that I get to do this work. The little kid in me is squealing every day. Just in the past few months, I’ve gotten to work alongside people in this theatre community that have taught me most of what I know: how to act, how to sing, how to dance, how to be gracious, how to be hard working, how to be professional. Performing beside some of them as a colleague, as well as sharing the stage with Broadway stars in AIDA, is a great gift. And performing at TPAC twice in a row? That’s almost as good as Broadway. I’m learning so much about myself, the craft of performing, and the industry. I’m just trying to soak in everything and take it one day at a time.
JHPEntertainment: What was your reaction to first reading the script for The Cake?
Maya Riley: I read the script the night before my callback. I wasn’t familiar with the play, but I’d heard of the playwright because of her work on the TV series This Is Us. When I read it, I got excited immediately. It’s so smartly written. The words jumped right off the page and grabbed me. These are people you know, this is the way people talk, these are issues we’re dealing with right now. That is a beautiful challenge as an actor. Lauren’s visionary and supportive direction is making me a more focused and engaging performer. My castmates are such a joy. I’ve known Mariah since we were kids performing in community theatre productions. Chris is a superb actor and wonderful to work with. And Megan is Nashville theatre royalty and so much fun! Having the opportunity to present this play with this lovely group of people is an honor.
JHPEntertainment: You play Macy the fiancée of Parris’ Jen. Jen’s White, Macy’s Black, they’re lesbians. She’s from the south, Macy’s a northerner. How important is it for you as an actress to take the occasional role with a message, even if, as in the case of The Cake, those messages might be sugar-coated (see what I did there?) in humor?
Maya Riley: For me, it’s incredibly important to tell stories that deal with current events, things that are happening today. I think people need stories that are simply entertaining, and also stories that are somewhat difficult to process. You need both, I think. There are a lot of projects that are one or the other. Not many plays can do both. This is what I love about The Cake. It will entertain you and have you rolling on the floor laughing one minute, then questioning that one interaction with your odd relative the next. It allows for you to be entertained while also sitting in some discomfort. I relish the opportunity to tackle a play that splits this difference so effortlessly. I’m so excited to see how audiences respond.
JHPEntertainment: While you grew up here in Nashville, after high school, you relocated to to New York, more than a few parallels with Macy. Have those similarities helped you develop her as a character?
Maya Riley: I think they have. When I lived in New York, I definitely had to develop that thick-skin, no-nonsense, demeanor. I also know what it’s like to come back down south and have to, let’s say, “readjust” to how things are down here. Which is something I can immediately connect with Macy. Honestly, Macy wasn’t a stretch for me to understand because our experiences are so similar. We belong to the same demographic, in more ways than one. I definitely think that being a southerner who has lived in New York helped me understand her. But I think I would have understood her anyway just because of our similarities. I know what it’s like to be a Black, queer woman in America. In that way, I know her pains, her hesitations, her joys, her comforts. Playing this role, in a way, is like communing with my mirror image. We got each other’s back, as we go through this play every night. At least, that’s how I like to think of it.
JHPEntertainment: What do you hope audiences take away from The Cake?
Maya Riley: I hope audiences take away a slice of cake and have a layered experience (wink)! The foundation of this play is love, which is what makes the stakes so high and the conflict so tense. The Cake is really a conversation in the shape of a play. My wish is that audiences truly take a bite, ride the waves of anger, laughter, and sorrow with us, and leave the theater with love and a deeper understanding of themselves or someone they care about.
For tickets to The Cake, CLICK HERE. Following their presentation of The Cake October 21-30, Nashville Rep continues their season with Elf: The Musical December 21-January 1, August Wilson’s Fences March 3-5, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night Time March 24-April 2 and Violet May 12-21. Season Tickets just went on sale earlier this week. CLICK HERE to purchase Season Tickets or for more info. Check out Nashville Rep online HERE and follow them on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and Instagram.
As always, if you wanna follow JHPEntertainment to find out who I’m chatting with for my next Rapid Fire Q&A, or for my take on the latest local and national theatre, music and movie offerings, find us at JHPEntertainment on Facebook, JHPEntertainment on Instagram and JHPEntertainment on Twitter. Got an event or show we should know about, drop us a line at the Contact tab. Till then, #GoSeeTheShow!