
It’s not every December that an Amish couple, a wannabe country-opera Santa, and a snowstorm collide… but in About The Town Productions’ newest musical comedy, JOLLY OL’ ST NICK: AN ACCIDENTAL CHRISTMAS MUSICAL COMEDY, written and directed by Wally Nason, holiday miracles come wrapped in the wonderfully unexpected. The show follows Simon and Eliza Yoder (Philip David Black and Catherine Birdsong), a spirited Amish couple whose calm Christmas Eve is upended by the arrival of Nick Goldstein (Jacob Waid) — a gigging Santa with big dreams, a bigger voice, and absolutely no idea what he’s walked into. With original songs, surprise medleys, laugh-out-loud storytelling, and a whole lot of heart, the show promises to be the kind of show that sneaks up on you in the best possible way. As the production prepares to hit the stage of various venues throughout Middle Tennessee December 6, 14, 17 & 20, we recently posed a few questions to the creator and cast for a festive Rapid Fire 20Q to talk musical mayhem, Santa suits, and the unexpected joy of this “accidental” Christmas musical.
_____
RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH CREATOR AND CAST OF JOLLY OL’ ST. NICK: AN ACCIDENTAL CHRISTMAS MUSICAL COMEDY
RAPID FIRE WITH PHILIP DAVID BLACK, SIMON IN JOLLY OL’ ST. NICK
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What part of Simon’s personality—his humor, faith, or honesty—do you most enjoy stepping into each night?
PHILIP DAVID BLACK: Simon, to me, juxtaposes very goofy humor with a very genuine faith. And that blend of tones – complete cheese with a sincere slice of religion – is always interesting to hold together moment to moment.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Simon’s a natural comedian—offering up several ‘dad jokes’. Aside from the one’s in the show, what’s your favorite joke to tell?
PHILIP DAVID BLACK: My go-to is always, “What do you call a cow with no legs? GROUND BEEF.” I won’t defend it, but it makes me laugh.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: If Simon could introduce one modern convenience into his Amish life, do you think he would, and if so, what might it be?
PHILIP DAVID BLACK: Simon mentions being cold several times during the play, and I assume he, like anyone, would appreciate being able to just flip a switch and make the house warmer. Winter is rough on all!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: The play reveals Simon and Eliza take a more minimalist approach to the holiday season, so, I gotta ask…in the Black household do you go all out with decorations or does your family enjoy a more subdued holiday celebration?
PHILIP DAVID BLACK: My wife is a Christmas enthusiast to the extreme. She had our two Christmas trees up this year last week BEFORE Thanksgiving Day, so – we are non-negotiably non-subdued so far as winter holidays go.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: With the arrival of Nick, Simon and Eliza experience what is likely their most memorable Christmas. What’s your favorite holiday memory from your childhood?
PHILIP DAVID BLACK: I grew up partially overseas due to my parents missionary work, and we spent Christmas one year outside of Prague in the Czech Republic. They have several interesting traditions there, such as holding a live “Christmas Carp” in the bathtub overnight to make fresh fish for Christmas. That was a standout for me as a kid – novelty wins.
RAPID FIRE WITH CATHERINE BIRDSONG, ELIZA IN JOLLY OL’ ST. NICK
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Eliza is excitable, curious and anything but quiet—what’s your favorite aspect of her personality that you’d like to lean into more in your own day-to-day attitude and actions?
CATHERINE BIRDSONG: I love that Eliza is very “go with the flow” she is willing to play all of the silly games Nick suggests, listen to all of the bad jokes Simon tells and she does so with a sincere interest in finding contentment in the small things. I think we could all learn from that mentality.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: The dual meaning of Eliza’s solo What’s He Hiding in the Bag is surprisingly thoughtful. What’s your favorite lyric of the number?
CATHERINE BIRDSONG: I really like the lyric “holy cow my flesh is weak” because it shows us that even people that we think are pure or religious are still faced with the same temptations as everyone else. I would imagine most people do not have a deep understanding of the Amish culture and would assume that they are perfect, but from Eliza’s story you certainly see that isn’t true…. Especially when she shares her Rumspringa story with Nick.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: In researching to chat with you, your director and your co-stars, I read the script. The idea of Christmas Carol Charades is so fun. If you were to play the game at you own family Christmas celebration, what tune would you choose and how would you act it out?
CATHERINE BIRDSONG: Rockin Around the Christmas Tree– I’d probably do some air guitar, run in a circle and pretend to be a tree!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Simon and Eliza are seen gathering up presents to take to their family’s Christmas Day celebration. Which got me to thinking…are you a Christmas Eve present opener, or do you wait until Christmas Day?
CATHERINE BIRDSONG: We kind of do both actually! Now that I have a little boy we do presents with his grandparents on Christmas Eve and then Santa (or Mrs. Claus) on Christmas morning!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I love that Wally’s script incorporates a bit of origin story of both the sacred and secular celebrations. In that spirit, which is a must-read during the holiday season, the story of the First Christmas or that of the Night Before Christmas?
CATHERINE BIRDSONG: The story of the First Christmas. That is a Christmas Eve tradition for certain. However, don’t get me wrong I love when Tim Allen reads the Night Before Christmas in the Santa Claus…. “There rose such a clatter”…
RAPID FIRE WITH JACOB WAID, NICK IN JOLLY OL’ ST. NICK
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Nick is a bit flawed. What’s your favorite aspect of the character?
JACOB WAID: My favorite thing about Nick is that he really embodies “the common man.” He’s a genuinely good guy with a huge heart, even if he gets a little lost and makes some questionable choices along the way. What I love is that he knows when he’s messed up and feels the weight of those decisions. I think audiences will see pieces of themselves in him – because his flaws and intentions are so human.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: As a key plot point, Nick accidentally shows up thinking he’s arrived as his latest Santa-gig, and during the course of the evening, he reveals he’s a former opera singer with aspirations of being a country music singer/songwriter. As a performer yourself, what’s the strangest gig you ever had?
JACOB WAID: Being part of a flash mob at a Walmart in rural Virginia probably takes the cake. It was one of those gigs where you ask yourself, “How did I end up here?” – but you just roll with it. The whole thing was chaotic, hilarious, and surprisingly fun. It definitely taught me early on that performing can take you to some unexpected places.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Pretty quickly into the action of the play, Nick reveals he often mixes up words. Is there a mixed up word within Nick’s dialogue that you’ve had the most trouble mixing up on purpose?
JACOB WAID: Can I say all of them? Memorizing something incorrectly is so much harder than people think. My brain constantly tries to auto-correct the words right before I say them, even though I know I’m supposed to mess them up. There’s a split-second battle in my head every time one of those mixed-up lines comes out. The two hardest ones for me are “breakheart” and “toothblue” my mind fights me the most on those every single time
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Nick’s solo, Cold and Alone reveals the character’s more vulnerable side. Do you have a particular way of tapping into that mindset as that number approaches?
JACOB WAID: For me, it all ties back to Nick being a representation of a “real person” who’s still “performing” for strangers while he’s sorting through his emotions. As the song approaches, I try to lean into those small cracks where his real thoughts and feelings slip through. You get these quick, honest flashes before he covers them up again with humor. I don’t think we see the fully unfiltered version of Nick until the last ten minutes of the show. To tap into those moments, I often think about my own life as a performer. The character you see onstage isn’t the full picture of who I am as a human, but little pieces of myself inevitably slip through when I am acting. Nick works the same way – you see flashes of his real heart underneath that gentle, Santa-esque façade. Leaning into that parallel helps me find his vulnerable side without forcing it.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Nick shares the real St. Nick’s origin story with Simon and Eliza, which got me to thinking…it’s not Christmas until my annual viewing of A Charlie Brown Christmas. What Christmas movie, special, song or story is your official start to the holiday season?
JACOB WAID: The Santa Clause with Tim Allen – that’s the one that officially kicks off the season. It’s a full tradition in my house: we decorate the tree and the whole place while that movie plays in the background. It just doesn’t feel like Christmas without it. And yes, I fully appreciate the irony, but sometimes the truth is stranger than fiction. Also our Christmas and Holiday festivities kick off on November 1st…yes, I am one of “those” Christmas people – hah!
RAPID FIRE WITH JOLLY OL’ ST. NICK PLAYWRIGHT WALLY NASON
JHPENTERTAINMENT: When you were writing Jolly Ol’ St. Nick: an ’Accidental’ Christmas Musical, was beginning the show with a song instead of some expositional dialogue a conscientious choice?
WALLY NASON: For sure! The truth is, it is always my preference to start a musical with a song. I like how a song can set up the tone of the whole show. Serious, mysterious, comedic or whatever. It can help establish a mood while simultaneously introducing characters and a sense of their personality.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I love the juxtaposition of the characters, a married Amish couple and a wannabe country singer. Did you base any of these characters on folks you’ve come across in real life?
WALLY NASON: Yes. I’ve spent over a decade working in Amish country America. I’ve written almost two dozen musicals and the majority of them opened in venues in Amish tourist communities. So I’ve done lots of research and established a lot of relationships with Amish people. The characters in Jolly Ol’ St. Nick represent a collection of stories and personalities that I came in contact with over the years. And the Nick… the wannabe country singer/mall Santa was a fun character I just created.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What’s your personal favorite holiday tradition that you enjoy with your own family?
WALLY NASON: We celebrate Thanksgiving and Christmas together with extended family on Thanksgiving day and the day after. There are usually 20+ people at our house sleeping on couches and air mattresses, eating all our meals together, falling over presents, arguing over phone chargers, and playing games. Loud and fun!
JHPENTERTAINMENT: I noticed you pepper a few of your original songs in this show with nods to some classic Christmas carol phrases. If you could give one classic Christmas song a full “Nason rewrite,” which one begs for your signature twist?
WALLY NASON: I did a ‘rewrite’ of Silent Night for another show that is one of my favorites. I added a beat box portion with an alternate melody and included part of the German text. I’d like to maybe try something like that with Oh Holy Night at some point.
JHPENTERTAINMENT: What do you hope audiences take with them after seeing Jolly Ol’ Saint Nick?
WALLY NASON: I hope people are inspired to do more to be understanding, empathetic, sensitive and intentional about encounters and relationships with people that are different than they are. This musical is really funny in presenting conversations where people are coming at life from very, very, different backgrounds and beliefs. And yet the brief time they spend together is meaningful and dare I say life-changing for both parties. You never know what people are dealing with and what they have had to overcome just to survive. I think we can all be better at including and celebrating those that are different than ourselves.
_____
From unexpected holiday guests to finding a bit of humor in the gentleness of Amish hospitality, the cast of Jolly Ol’ Saint Nick proves that some of the best holiday stories are the ones we never see coming. Wally Nason and his trio of performers blend warmth, whimsy, and a dash of Christmas chaos into a musical that reminds us all that surprises — even the uninvited ones — can be the beginning of something magical.
You can catch Jolly Ol’ Saint Nick at one of four performances across Middle Tennessee:
December 6 – 3:00pm – Life Church Nashville (215 Broadmoor Dr.)
December 14 – 3:00pm – Jenkins Church Nolensville (2501 York Rd.)
December 17 – 7:00pm – Williamson County Performing Arts Center (112 Everbright Ave., Franklin)
December 20 – 3:00pm – Playhouse 615 (11920 Lebanon Rd., Mt. Juliet)
CLICK HERE and use the drop-down menu to select specific date/location.
To learn more about About The Town Productions and to keep up with their next production, CLICK HERE.
As always, if you wanna follow JHPEntertainment to find out who I’m chatting with for my next Rapid Fire Q&A, or for my take on the latest local and national theatre, music and movie offerings, visit JHPENTERTAINMENT.com or FOLLOW US on Facebook, Insta and X. Until then… #GoSeeTheShow!

RAPID FIRE WITH 



RAPID FIRE 20Q WITH MAGNHILD
JHPENTERTAINMENT: Last year, you released your debut single Maybe, then the follow-up, 17 and now you’ve got Ending. How excited are you for listeners to hear the new track as they continue to discover you as an up-and-coming artist?
JHPENTERTAINMENT: As a songwriter, what’s your creative process like? Do you set aside a certain time daily to explore lyric ideas and melodies, or do you take a more organic approach?
JHPENTERTAINMENT: With Ending now streaming, is there any talk of a music video? How would you like to see it visualized?






RAPID FIRE WITH THE SPARKLEY CLEAN FUNERAL SINGERS’ JUNIE LASHLEY, ACTRESS AND PLAYWRIGHT, LORI FISHCHER
RAPID FIRE WITH THE SPARKLEY CLEAN FUNERAL SINGERS’ LASHLEY
RAPID FIRE WITH THE SPARKLEY CLEAN FUNERAL SINGERS’ PASTOR PHIL, ROBERT COLES
RAPID FIRE WITH THE SPARKLEY CLEAN FUNERAL SINGERS’ LYLE LASHLEY, ALAN LEE
RAPID FIRE WITH SAYRE CO-PLAYWRIGHT, BEL STUART
RAPID FIRE WITH SAYRE’s MEMORY, TAMESHIA MARTIN
RAPID FIRE WITH SAYRE’s ECHO, MANDY MOON
RAPID FIRE WITH SAYRE CO-PLAYWRIGHT EMILY DODSON


RAPID FIRE Q&A WITH TAMIKO ROBINSON STEELE, CAMAE IN NASHVILLE REP’s THE MOUNTAINTOP