Technically, The 25th Annual Putnam Country Spelling Bee, currently onstage at The Larry Keeton Theatre through October 27, isn’t Suzanne Spooner-Faulk’s debut as a director, I say technically because she co-directed the company’s production of Big River last year. It is, however, her first time to fully helm a show and to no surprise to anyone who knows her, she does so to a joyful end, presenting a show brimming with charm, humor, heart and just enough silliness to make watching a show in which adults play school-age children competing in a Spelling Bee worth watching. Doesn’t hurt matters that The Keeton itself use to be a local school, so the auditorium vibe that still exists in the theatre space perfectly adds to the play’s gymnasium setting.
For her cast, Spooner-Faulk has assembled a fun mix of actors, some of whom are returning to Keeton having previously been seen on stage, and a couple making their Keeton debut…always a welcomed choice to mix it up a bit. While it can be nice to have a company that’s completely familiar, that can sometimes result in a few miscast roles. Luckily for Spelling Bee audiences, that is not the case here, as each and every actor involved manages to find their individual character’s quirks and run with them.
Cast as the quirky spellers are Chelsea Pearce, Jason Scott, Miranda Vaqué, Toby Turner, Sydney Rogers, and Jonathan Hunter. Playing the equally quirky adult roles are David Shaw, Drew Dunlop and Jena Salb.
Once the show begins, Salb’s Rona Lisa Peretti takes to the Putnam County gymnasium to moderate the Bee. My Favorite Moment of the Bee features Salb’s Rona Lisa as she reminisces her own championship win some years back. As Rona Lisa, Salb is as perky and excited to be par too the Bee legacy as she is sweet when, during various circumstances in the show, the kids need a little bit of adult support and understanding. Having never seen Salb on stage myself, I am happy to proclaim she’s now among my ever-growing list of theatre crushes.
Joining Salb’s Rona Lisa as the Bee’s sole judge/word pronouncer is Drew Dunlop as Vice Principal Douglas Panch. Dunlop is at his best when he’s interacting with additional Bee contestants pulled from the show’s actual audience. (More about that later)
The third and final adult role comes in the form of David Shaw as Mitch Mahoney, the Bee’s comfort counselor. That’s right, it’s Mahoney’s job to send the losers off with a hug and a juice box. Shaw’s Mitch is delightful. Like several of his castmates, Shaw also appears in an additional role, playing one of two gay dads to one of the kids. You gotta love the stereotypical flamboyance of his gay dad portrayal as well as the equally expected thug look of his portrayal of Mitch, both as wrong and un-PC, funny is funny and Shaw is funny.
Then there’s the kids. Pearce, as Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre, the youngest contestant in the Bee, who just so happens to have two gay dads, is hilarious. Her affected way of speaking—as if she were wearing braces—and her spot-on comedic timing are the perfect combination. Proving just how quick on her feet she is on and off-book, during last weekend’s Sunday matinee when a plane seemed to be about to land on the rooftop of The Keeton Theatre, without missing a beat—and totally in character as Logainne, Pearce cracked wise that her current spelling word “made as much sense as building a community center so close to an airport”.
Scott, as returning Bee champ, Charlito “Chip” Tolentino gets his own chance to steal the spotlight in one of the show’s more surprising musical numbers, My Unfortunate Erection. Yes, you read that right, Chip, like most teenage boys experiences a sudden urge right there in the middle of the Bee. As one of the elderly ladies seated near me said at the close of his number “Oh, my! It’s like that Justin Timberlake SNL song-skit”.
Sydney Rogers, a newcomer to Keeton, plays Spelling Bee newcomer, Olive Ostrovsky. Of all the characterizations of the spellers, Rogers’ Olive truly tugs at the heartstrings as she’s just as concerned with spelling as she is her father’s absence from the audience. Early in the show, she leads the company in My Friend, the Dictionary, a telling tune that touches home with the outcast in all of us.
To be completely honest, upon first glance, Toby Turner seemed a bit miscast as William Barfeé (it’s pronounced Bar-fay), but once he gets his magic foot in motion, he proves why he was cast, as he turns what could easily be the most annoying character in the show into one of the most endearing.
Vaqué’s Marcy Park is a little Wednesday Addams, a little Buffy Summers (sans the penchant for taking out vampires). The character’s quirkiness comes from a mix of being new to the area, speaking a multitude of languages and being an over-achiever. Vaqué’s lead on I Speak Six Languages is one of the show’s more thoughtful tunes and she delivers it with just the right punch of emotion.
Rounding out the Spelling Bee contestants is Jonathan Hunter as Leaf Coneybear. Described in the playbill as being homeschooled, Hunter’s Leaf is simply my favorite. Wearing a safety helmet, a shimmering gold lame cape and clothes his character bravely admits to designing himself, Hunter’s Leaf reminded me so much of this goofy kid I went to elementary school with, it’s scary. Of course I can’t name names, he’s probably some multimillionaire inventor by now anyway. But back to Hunter, he manages to steal every scene he’s in and his solo on I’m Not That Smart will make you wanna go hug him.
While these nine actors make up the cast, as indicated earlier, several of the characters also play additional minor roles as various members of the Bee contestants’ families. Also mentioned above, during each performance, four members of the audience are called up to the stage and treated as late entries to the Spelling Bee. That’s part of the charm of the show. No two shows are ever the same, in part because you just never know how the audience pulls are going to interact with the actual cast. Luckily for me and the audience during the show I attended, a couple of the audience pulls were more than ready for their fifteen minutes of fame. Don’t worry though, unlike some productions I’ve seen, the audience pulls do so willingly as they’re asked just prior to curtain if they’d be wiling to participate.
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee continues its run at The Larry Keeton Dinner Theatre (108 Donelson Pike) with evening performances Thursday, October 18 thru Saturday, October 27 with dinner service at 6 p.m. and show beginning at 7 p.m. Dinner and Show tickets are $30 for Adults, $20 for Children 12 and under OR Show Only tickets for $25 for Adults or $15 for Children 12 and Under. Call 615.883.8375 for tickets and availability.
Next up at The Larry Keeton Dinner Theatre is A Christmas Carol: The Musical with shows from November 29-December 16. CLICK HERE for tickets or more information.
To keep up with the latest from The Larry Keeton Dinner Theatre, follow them on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.
Interested in coverage for your latest entertaining endeavor? Click the contact page and drop me a note. You can also follow JHP Entertainment on Instagram and Facebook.