
God’s Favorite, now onstage at Chaffin’s Barn thru June 22 may not be as widely known as legendary playwright Neil Simon’s other works like The Odd Couple or his somewhat autobiographical Brighton Beach Memoirs, Biloxi Blues and Broadway Bound, but when presented by one of Nashville’s favorite theatre companies, especially when under the direction of Joy Tilley Perryman and featuring several Music City favorites among the cast, rest assured the laughs are heaven-sent.
With a plot that heavily borrows from THE Good Book’s story of Job, God’s Favorite swaps the biblical leading man’s name from Job to Joe, Joe Benjamin at that, perhaps a wink to the $100 bill, for you see, Joe is a wealthy cardboard box magnate who’s trust in God and love of his family has showered him with success and happiness.
Set in the 1970s, complete with a perfectly retro wardrobe courtesy Miriam Creighton and a simplistic but groovy set, lighting and overall look from Perryman’s technical team including stage manager Catherine Forman, sound engineer Stephen Platea, lighting designer Austin Olive, set construction by Robin Lawshe and production assistance from Delaying Rizer, the play begins at the stroke of midnight when a mysterious stranger arrives at Joe’s home and reveals that he is indeed God’s Favorite, but that his trust in the lord will be tested unless he renounces him.
While this may not read like the stuff of which a Neil Simon comedy is made, you just have to have a little faith in Perryman and company to deliver the goods. Resplendent with seventies references including nods to The Exorcist, Robert Redford, a hilarious bit of schtick involving a rotary phone and such, the script may seem dated at times, but Perryman takes full advantage, even having her sound guy play a bit of The Exorcist theme between scenes just when things start to go awry for Joe and family.
Leading the cast is John Mauldin, who in the last few years has indeed become a Chaffin’s favorite. As Joe, Mauldin is the perfect embodiment of the ‘everyman’. Jolly and pleased with his happy life, Mauldin’s Joe brings to mind Archie Bunker…if Archie were ever in a great mood. Even when tested with the loss of his business, plagued with aches and pains and the destruction of his home, Maudlin’s Joe keeps his positivity, an aspect I suspect the actor himself maintains in his real life.
Cast opposite Mauldin is yet another Barn Dinner favorite, Jenny Wallace as Joe’s wife, Rose. Having made her Chaffin’s debut three decades ago, Wallace has appeared in some three dozen plays at The Barn. As Rose, Wallace at first seems the typical well-bred, well-off woman, first appearing oblivious to any and all slightly uncomfortable situations around her, but as Joe’s faith is tested, Wallace’s Rose seems to have a bit of a metamorphosis as she comes to also value the importance of familial love over material belongings.
Speaking of familiar love, The Benjamin’s are blessed with three young offspring. Returning for his third and most significant role to date at Chaffin’s is Elijah Wallace as David Benjamin, the family’s eldest son and a bit of a seemingly lost cause. Having enjoyed Wallace in his campily flamboyant portrayal as Charles Nelson Reilly in The Barn’s The Game Show Show during the holiday season, I was happy to see him take on this role. Though peppered with easy-target drunk jokes and pratfalls, the role of David provides some of the show’s most poignant moments and Wallace handles the range of his character with ease and conviction.
Marking his debut performance at The Barn is Ben Woods as Ben Benjamin. Most of Wood’s on-stage time is shared Annika Burley as Sarah Benjamin, Ben’s twin sister. You’d never know these two weren’t longstanding members of the Chaffin’s family, as they fit easily into the comfortable, fun atmosphere. At the top of the show there’s a running gag of young Sarah repeating every line spoken by her father and brother. Under the direction of a less-confident director, this scene—heck, this entire play—could easily play a bit droll and reaching for obvious laughs, but with Perryman at the helm, it’s truly charming and unexpectedly though-provoking.
Speaking of Perryman, in addition to directing, she also appears in the show, playing Mady, one of The Benjamins’ servants. Like Mauldin and Wallace and Wood and Burley, Perryman is also paired with a recurring scene partner throughout the show in the form of yet another Chaffin’s favorite, Charlie Winton as Morris, The Benjamin’s butler. Perryman and Winton are relegated to brief scenes, but as seasoned performers, they make the most of their time on stage and are always a delight.
Rounding out the cast is Scott Stewart as Sidney Lipton, the aforementioned mysterious guest who…Spoiler Alert…is actually a messenger from God…or maybe Satan…I”m still not 100% clear on that. Nonetheless, Stewart, yes, another Barn favorite, is an absolute joy to watch. It’s funny that I mentioned Charles Nelson Reilly earlier in this review…interesting because Reilly created the role of Sidney Lipton in the original 1974 Broadway production of God’s Favorite. For Scott’s Sidney, he goes the nebbish nerdy route, and he does so perfectly, affecting his normally commanding voice to come across a bit more uncertain and nervous. But you gotta love when Sidney is pushed and needs to be a bit more assertive, Stewart belts out a booming line or two that are divine indeed.
As is typical for a Neil Simon play, the jokes come at you at lightning speed, one-liner after one-liner, typically served with a heavy dose of sarcasm and wit, but it’s the not-so-hidden message behind the laughs, the message of faith and family that makes this little charmer worth the watch.
While the plot is outrageous at times and the resolution a bit unbelievable and ever-so neatly packaged within the show’s two-hour run-time, as presented by director Perryman and stars Mauldin, Stewart and company, God’s Favorite will surely be a favorite amongst Chaffin’s patrons.

God’s Favorite continues at Chaffin’s Barn Dinner Theatre with shows through June 22. Showtimes are Thursdays at 12 noon, Friday and Saturday evenings at 7:30p.m. and a Sunday, June 16 matinee at 2 p.m. Tickets range in price from $13 for Children 12 and under and $20 for Youth/Student tickets to $35 for Adults. CLICK HERE to purchase tickets.
Being Nashville oldest continuing dinner theatre, Chaffin’s also offers a few dining options in addition to the show ticket pricing. As always, there’s the buffet option, or patrons can also choose items from an a la carte dinner menu with a full range of starters, small plates and desserts. CLICK HERE to check out the menu.
Up next at Chaffin’s Barn Dinner Theatre will be the family favorite, Annie, on the MainStage from July 11-August 3. CLICK HERE for tickets or for more information. To keep up with the latest from Chaffin’s Barn Dinner Theatre, find them online at ChaffinsBarnTheatre.com, ’like’ them on Facebook and follow them on Instagram and Twitter.
Interested in coverage for your latest entertaining endeavor? Click the contact page and drop me a note. You can also follow JHP Entertainment on Instagram and Facebook.


I could go on an on about Buckley’s performance and yes, she could absolutely simply stand on stage and sing each of the songs from Hello Dolly in concert and thrill audiences, but alas there’s more to Hello Dolly than Dolly Levi. For starters, Lewis J. Stadlen as the aforementioned Horace Vandergelder perfectly embraces the time period as the blustering, and frequently flustered half-millionaire. Part Al Lewis, part Jimmy Durante, part Burgess Meredith, Stadlen is indeed the perfect match and compliment to Buckley’s Levi.
Then there’s the two young gentlemen who work for Horace, Cornelius Hackl and Barnaby Tucker (Nic Rouleau and Sean Burns), who decide to follow Dolly and Horace on an adventure to New York City with the simple goal of kissing young ladies while in the big city. Dolly and the young Yonkers residents are all showcased in one of Act 1’s most gorgeous numbers, Put on Your Sunday Clothes, one of my many personal favorite tunes in the show. During this number, its more than evident why scene and costume designer Santo Loquasto won one of the revival’s four Tony Awards, as the costumes are absolutely stunning.
As Act 1 winds down, the audience is treated to Dancing, a nearly all-in, all-out choreo number that builds the anticipation of the inevitable pairings.
Truth be told, Act 2 begins with what I consider the weakest number, Penny in My Pocket, but with Stadlen performing it as what is essentially a one man solo vaudeville number directly addressing the audience, it works.




Of the musical highlights, Joy Franz and young Victoria Bingham as The Dowager Empress and Young Anastasia get this off on a high note with the above-referenced show-opening Once Upon A December. It’s such a touching moment and completely serves to set up the relationship between Anastasia and her elder relative, a vital point within the tale’s featured plotline.
Another bright, undeniable high point comes in Act Two when Vlad and Lily (one of the conmen and the Dowager Empress’ Lady in Waiting) duet on The Countess and The Common Man. The comedic timing and hilarious physicallity of Tari Kelly as The Countess Lily and Edward Staudenmayer as Vlad during this number evokes memories of Carol Burnett and Harvey Korman during their heyday on The Carol Burnette Show, spoofing many an overly melodramatic film classic. A scene perfectly suited for this show that oftentimes gets a bit bogged down in its own grand airs.











While many in the Nashville area (myself among them) associate the iconic singer and the nearly-equally beloved musical with local mega-talent Mandy Barnett, who’s many performances in the role are as near to seeing Cline herself as anyone can get, director Benji Kern and star Chambers make wise choices in the way Chambers presents Cline. While Barnett mystifyingly embodies the icon, so much so, you might begin to believe in reincarnation, Chambers makes her turn as Cline her own, and in doing so, putting the emphasis on both jukebox and musical, offering audiences something between a tribute show and a modern take on the esteemed theatrical piece and the woman for whom the show is named.




























Act 2 kicks off with the high-energy Get on Your Feet and just as quickly gets to the drama of the story with strain between Gloria and her mother, and the inevitable retelling of the tragic bus accident that nearly caused Gloria’s life, ability to walk and her career. These plot lines are highlighted by musical interludes as varied as 1991’s Live for Loving You, Oye Mi Canto (from Gloria’s first solo project in 1990) and If I Never Get to Tell You, a song with lyrics by Gloria and music by her and Emilio’s daughter, Emily Estefan, that was written specifically for the musical. 






